Can't find a hygienist no matter how hard you look? Jeff breaks down what's really happening with the hygienist shortage and shares practical strategies for finding and hiring hygienists, even in the toughest markets.
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
Should a general dentist do their own hygiene?
Not if the practice has enough patients to justify a hygienist, even one day a week. Jeff says the dentist is far more valuable doing dentistry. A busy doctor can produce $1,000 to $2,000 an hour, while a high-performing hygienist produces $300 to $400, and even the average GP comes out to roughly $460 to $660 per clinical hour on ADA figures. A busy hygiene department is also the practice's main patient retention tool.
Why is it so hard to find a dental hygienist?
According to the ADA Health Policy Institute figures Jeff cites, 88.3% of dentists recruiting a hygienist say it's very or extremely challenging, and only 42% filled the position. There are about 222,740 employed hygienists, but many work part-time. In a Florida survey, 40% worked under 31 hours a week. Jeff's rough estimate is that the country is short tens of thousands of full-time hygienists, and nearly three in 10 hygienists say they plan to retire by 2030.
How many hygienists should a general dentist have?
Jeff recommends about 1.5 hygienists per dentist, and up to two is workable. At one-to-three, the doctor is pulled into so many hygiene exams that their own procedures suffer and the schedule stretches. At one-to-one or less, there isn't enough hygiene to support the practice.
What steps should you take to find a hygienist?
Escalate one step at a time. First, run competitive ads (Indeed shows local pay rates), ask your team and supply rep, and use temps or temp-to-hire so hygiene days don't go empty. Next, try an employment service, hygiene Facebook groups, local hygiene schools, and your state association. Then recruit statewide, with virtual interviews, a paid trial week, and relocation help, plus bulk emails through hygiene publications. After that, look at neighboring states with easy licensure by endorsement.
How do you know if your hygiene department is growing enough?
Track the number of recall visits. Each new patient adds at least two hygiene visits a year, so the number should always grow. Jeff's rule of thumb: if you add 25 to 30 new patients a month, you should add one day of weekly hygiene per year. A hygienist who stays booked is not enough. If the hygiene schedule isn't growing, the practice isn't keeping its patients.
Episode Transcript
-
Funny thing: over the past few years, I'm seeing more doctors doing their own hygiene than at any other point in my career. In certain cases, they're doing it to save money, because hygienists are "expensive." I'm doing quotation fingers there. And sure, hygienists come at a premium, but if you're a GP with enough patients to justify having a hygienist and you're still doing your own hygiene, you're making a big mistake. You're far more valuable to your practice doing dentistry, and having a hygienist would enable you not only to make more profit, but to provide better service to your patients.
If you've just started a new practice, only have a few patients, and are doing your own hygiene, well, I understand that. But when you get to the point where you could justify bringing one in, even if it's for one day a week, you should do so. Bottom line: a productive, busy hygiene department is your primary patient retention tool and vital to a successful general dental practice.
Now, let's say you have no hygienist because you just can't find one. Well, unfortunately, that's not a unique problem right now. It's an issue industry-wide. How big an issue? Well, the ADA Health Policy Institute put out its latest quarterly survey this past month of dentists who are recruiting a hygienist, and right now 88.3%, and I know I'm not supposed to use the decimal points, my editors hate it, but whatever, 88.3% of the doctors surveyed say it's very or extremely challenging to find one. And only 42%, less than half of them, actually filled the position. Yeah, not even half.
All right, so I just mentioned how hygienists are a vital part of a general dental practice, and more than half of the doctors can't find one. So what's happening here? What's the current situation with the hygiene labor force, and where does it look like things are going? And more importantly, if you're trying to find a hygienist, what should you do? What do we recommend to our clients to fill that position? That's what I want to cover in this episode. My name is Jeff Blumberg, and I'm your host.
Why don't we start with where things are now, beginning with the dental hygiene labor force in the United States. In May of 2025, because these big nationwide surveys tend to have a delay, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said there were about 222,740 hygienists employed in the US. So, not bad.
And how many new hygienists are we making? The schools are actually pretty busy. The ADA's surveys of dental hygiene programs, reported last December, showed a record 17,000 students enrolled and 7,700 graduates in 2024. I'm cutting off the small numbers, by the way. It was actually 7,739, just to sound exact. And the ADA Health Policy Institute said in April that first-year enrollment is up 16% since 2020. So this is growing. Again, not too terrible.
So we see how many we have, and we see how many are joining the workforce. What does the other side of the equation look like? How many are leaving? According to DentalPost's 2026 salary report, nearly three in 10 hygienists plan to retire by 2030, so within the next four years. If we look at the roughly 220,000 hygienists, three in 10 of those, or 30%, is 66,000, if my math is correct, who plan on retiring in the next four years. And burnout is real. The staffing platform GoTu and the American Dental Hygienists' Association said in April that 60.6% of hygienists report burnout.
And then there's another aspect of this, which we all know about but which doesn't show up in these numbers. I'm going to use an example outside of dentistry to illustrate my point. Let's say you own a law firm, and you're trying to hire 10 full-time lawyers. You're very busy. You see that the, quote-unquote, "supply of available lawyers" is 20 people. Okay, so you're in the game. You need 10, and there are 20 available. Then you find out that half of the 20 are part-time. So 10 of them work half the week. From a full-time perspective, if one full-time lawyer equals one lawyer, two part-time lawyers equal one lawyer. I don't know why I'm using a lawyer example, but whatever. So 10 full-time and 10 part-time lawyers is actually 15 lawyers. Do you see?
So how does this apply to what I'm talking about? Well, the Florida Department of Health surveyed the state's hygienists and found that 40.45% of practicing hygienists work under 31 hours a week, and 90% of them are not looking to take on more hours.
So let's expand this out nationally and assume it doesn't apply only to Florida. Again, I'm estimating here, folks. I don't have stats for every state, but I deal with doctors from all over the US and Canada, and there are a lot of part-time hygienists. If you hear 222,000 hygienists nationwide, that number overstates the real supply. If you use the hours from that Florida survey, the average hygienist works about 28 and a half hours a week. Every 10 hygienists you see on a license list is really about seven or fewer full-time hygienists in a chair.
Why does this matter? Well, for starters, we don't have as many hygienists as we think. If we apply this 40% number from Florida to the 222,000 hygienists nationwide, we get the equivalent working hours of approximately 138,000 to 158,000 full-time hygienists. So we have 222,000 employed, but if you factor in the part-time numbers, using Florida as an example, we really only have the equivalent of 138,000 to 158,000 full-time hygienists.
So let's compare this to doctors. The ADA Health Policy Institute said there were 205,088 dentists in the United States in 2025, and about 78.8% of them are general dentists. That's 161,600 GPs. Assuming the vast majority of GPs are full-time, we see that we have fewer hygienists than GPs, or at least the numbers are pretty close.
So why does this matter? Let's look at how this works in a GP practice. There's a ratio we normally explain to our clients for where you want to be with hygienists. Let's say you're a GP listening to this, and I want you to imagine you have three full-time hygienists. That would actually be great from a hygiene flow perspective, but it would be counterproductive for you as a dentist. Sometimes you'd be doing three hygiene checks an hour. If you book that against trying to do a productive procedure, it starts to make your schedule stretch longer than it should. Versus, let's say you don't have a hygienist, and then you've got nothing going on.
So what's the ideal number? What we've found is that the ideal is about one doctor to every 1.5 hygienists. It could be one to two. That's not terrible. That's doable. One to three gets to be undoable. And obviously, one to one or less is not enough. So one doctor to 1.5 hygienists, up to one to two.
So if that's the ratio we're working with, based on the patient flow that should be going on in a practice, and we take the roughly 161,000 to 162,000 GPs and multiply by 1.5, we get 241,000. That's how many hygienists we would need. We have 161,000 doctors, and we need 241,000 hygienists to accommodate this one-to-1.5 factor. So we're well short. Again, the Bureau of Labor Statistics says we have 222,740 employed hygienists, and 40% are potentially part-time. But even with just the number employed, 222,000, when we need 241,000, we're short 20,000 immediately.
But because a lot of these hygienists are part-time, the shortfall is actually closer to 60,000 to 80,000, because, as we went over earlier, the full-time equivalent we have is about 140,000 to 150-some thousand. It's a rough estimate, not an official number, but the point is that we're short by tens of thousands of full-time hygienists, not just a few thousand. And this checks out: the ADA Health Policy Institute said in April of this year that only 60% of dentists say they have enough hygienists.
So what does this look like going forward? And I'm not even factoring in the three out of 10 who say they're leaving. That's something I didn't even want to get into. But hygienist jobs will grow. The projection is from 225,000 to 243,000 by 2035. That's 8% growth, with about 15,000 openings per year. But that 2035 number, 241,000 to 243,000, is roughly what we need today, and that's before you account for part-time.
So essentially what you've got is a lower supply and lots of people, meaning dentists, fighting for the same resource. It's a labor market. If you're a prospective employee, you can choose where you want to go work. Obviously it's not all about money, but that's part of it, along with what's a good fit for you, or whatever your criteria are as a prospective employee. But in any market, if a resource or service is rare, you're going to pay more for it. That's a seller's market. If I'm the only person who can do what I do, and lots of people want that service, I'm going to be able to command a premium for it. If lots of people do what I do and there's not as much demand, I'm going to take less money for it. That's generally how it works: a buyer's market versus a seller's market.
So right now we have a seller's market, and the wages show it. The Bureau of Labor Statistics said the median hygienist wage went from almost $78,000 in May of 2021 to $98,000 in May of 2025. That's up about 26%. During that same period, '21 to '25, inflation went up 19%, so hygiene wages are actually beating inflation.
So with all this going on, hygienists are a bit rarer than front desk employees, or even dental assistants for that matter. So how do you get one in a very competitive market? Well, to begin with, it gets a little regionally weird. Some areas have a lot of hygienists, and some are tight. The best bellwether for this, in my opinion, is Indeed. I used to recommend other services for this, but Indeed is the best, because it shows you right now who's looking to hire, how many employment ads there are, and what people are paying.
This is always good. When you want to place an ad, you don't want to come in advertising for someone at the front for $20 when everybody else is advertising at $25. Your ad's not going to get clicked. So it's a great bellwether. If you go to Indeed and look around at different areas of the country, you'll see that some areas are paying very high, with signing bonuses, and other areas are paying much lower, and that usually tells you about the supply in that area.
For instance, I saw more ads for hygienists in Omaha, Nebraska than in Miami, Florida, which is counterintuitive, because Miami is a much bigger city than Omaha. So I went back and got the numbers. When I looked on Simply Hired, which is part of the Indeed family, there were 33 hygienist listings in Omaha and 17 in Miami. For comparison, Tampa had 39. If you line that up against how many hygienists work there, look at this. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says Omaha has about 580 hygienists, and Miami has 3,460. So per working hygienist, Omaha had about 11 times as many open ads as Miami.
And here's my favorite part, and the reason I'm picking Omaha. When I looked at the Miami ads, one of the hygienist ads in Miami was from a practice in Omaha, Nebraska. The title was literally "Relocate to Nebraska: Registered Dental Hygienist, $50 to $53 an hour."
And if you look at the pay, this is where it gets interesting. I've lived in Miami for a while. I've never been to Omaha. I've heard it's really cool. But look at the pay. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median hygienist in Omaha makes $94,170 a year. In Miami, the median is $82,780. So think about that for a second. A hygienist in Omaha is making almost $12,000 more a year than in Miami. And as a point of comparison, the cost of living in Miami is 24% higher than in Omaha. So Miami hygienists already earn less than in Omaha, and adjusted for cost of living, an Omaha hygienist's pay is worth about $117,000 in Miami, roughly 41% more buying power.
So the hygienist in Miami makes less and also pays more to live there, which is probably why you see this "Relocate to Nebraska" ad. Obviously, again, I've never been to Omaha. I hear it's cool. But there are certain virtues if you like Miami. If you like the water, I assume it's probably going to be better for you than living in Omaha. Anyway, that was my point. I was a bit shocked when I saw that. "Come live in Omaha" was the last thing I expected to see. They may be advertising in other metro areas as well. But ultimately, what have we got? More hygienists in Miami, lower pay, and fewer ads. That's a market with more supply. Then you'll have areas with less supply, et cetera. But overall, nationally, we have a supply issue.
So where does this leave you? What should you do if you can't find a hygienist? Here's what I would do. I'm going to give you a series of steps that escalate. I'd start at the beginning, and if I'm getting no progress from that, I'd move to the next one, and the next one, and so on. If you have a large supply, you might get your hygienist with the first step. If you have a low supply in your area, you might be on step four or five before you find who you're looking for.
So what do you do first? Obviously, place your ads, on Indeed, DentalPost, et cetera, and make sure your pay and benefits are competitive. Talk to your supply rep, talk to anybody you know, and talk to your staff. They may have worked with other hygienists before. Anybody you can bring in. You could temp or hire part-timers in the meantime. If you temp to hire, according to Cloud Dentistry, nearly 60% of the practices on its platform hired a temp permanently. So temp-to-hire could work. You could bring in a couple of part-timers to make it work in the interim, depending on availability. But while you're placing your ad, you don't want to have no hygienist. I would at least temp.
Step two. Let's say step one is getting you nothing. You could use an employment service, or you could expand where you're advertising for hygienists beyond job ads: publications they read, hygiene Facebook groups, the local hygiene school's job board, your state hygiene association, et cetera.
What would I do from there? Let's say I've done all that. I've got my ads out. I'm in Facebook groups. One of my staff joined a hygiene Facebook group, and they're talking about it in there, and still nothing. I still can't find anybody. What do you do? Now I would go statewide. Let's say you're in Tampa Bay, which is where I am. There are a lot of hygienists in Miami, and as we just saw, Miami pays less. So I'd start in my own state and probably put some ads in Miami: "Want to relocate to Tampa?"
And how would I do this? I'd probably do the interview virtually. Get the application filled out, get the resume, et cetera, and do the interview virtually. Maybe bring them up for a week or two to work. Put them in one of those extended-stay hotels with a kitchen and so on. I'd pay for their travel to come up, and if it works out, I might even kick in to help with the relocation costs, with the idea that they're going to stick around for a while. You can always have something drafted by your attorney.
Eventually, you'll find somebody who might be willing to relocate. We had a lot of clients do this after the pandemic. For instance, we had a client in New York State, out in the middle of nowhere, who advertised in New York City, because there were people who didn't like living in a one-bedroom apartment and wanted a backyard, and they can't have that in New York City. So you can advertise within your state, because then you don't have a licensing issue.
There's another interesting pool, which I don't quite know how to tap. If I sat and looked at it a bit, I could probably figure it out. As an example, the Florida Department of Health found 3,600 people who hold a Florida hygiene license but don't practice in Florida. I don't know where they're practicing. Maybe they want to come back to Florida.
And this is where I would get smart, or inventive, with this stuff. If I've hit the point where my normal local ads aren't working and I'm advertising in other cities in my state to get a hygienist, I would also look at hygiene publications. There's the Journal of Dental Hygiene, and there are different clinical publications for hygienists as well. You don't necessarily want to advertise in the magazine itself. I can tell you from an MGE perspective that I get fewer bites advertising in a magazine than with a banner ad on their website. You might look at something like that.
What's a bit quicker, and can reach more potential leads, is that a lot of these companies will do a bulk email for you, and they're very reasonable. It could be a few thousand bucks, up to $5,000, depending on who you're doing it with. And I don't know that they all do this. There are numerous publications for dental hygienists, and I don't know what their rules are. But in some cases, you could reach out and say, "Look, I'm looking for a hygienist, and I'd like to send out a bulk email," and they offer a bulk email service. They'll probably say so in the media guide on their website. You pay a couple thousand bucks, you write a nice short email about what you're looking for, and you may get some bites that way. They can possibly filter the list by state, so if I'm advertising within my state, that might be another way to reach people, outside of putting Indeed ads in other cities. Things of that nature.
Now let's say I can't find a hygienist in my state. I've done all of this. Where do I go next? I would go to neighboring states. And keep in mind, I'm temping in the meantime. I don't want to have open hygiene days. But before I went to neighboring states, I would look at reciprocity.
It really depends. For example, let's say you're in Indiana and you advertise in Ohio. An Ohio hygienist moving to Indiana goes through Indiana's endorsement rules: they have to have actively practiced two of their last five years. And this is not legal advice, by the way. You should find this out for yourself. Fourteen hours of continuing ed in the last two years, three letters from dentists, a $100 fee, a background check, and a short jurisprudence exam.
Florida has endorsement now too. Under a Florida statute passed as part of the MOBILE Act, a hygienist with an active, clean license from another state who has practiced two of the last four years can get licensed here. Again, this is not definitive legal advice. You have to check this for yourself. And the state is supposed to issue the license within seven days of a completed application.
So before I go to other states, I would ask, "What's the reciprocity like here? How easy is it to get a hygienist from this other state licensed in my state?" Then you can advertise in those states on Indeed, like the Nebraska practice advertising in Miami. You could also possibly email hygienists in those states, if you can work with some of these publications that do bulk emails. You want to find states where it's easy to get a hygienist licensed in your state. You don't want a long process. You want it to be quick, with less friction.
And there I would apply the same thing I'd do if a hygienist came up from Miami to Tampa. I'd do the interview. If I want to hire them, great. I'm going to put them in some type of temporary housing, an extended-stay hotel or something, I'm going to pay for their travel, and I'd probably kick in for their moving costs. If I'm bringing them in from another state, obviously, first I decide I want to hire them, and then they have to get licensed. That would be a condition of getting hired. Then, assuming they're licensed, I'd do the same thing: fly them in, put them up, and have them work a couple of weeks. If you really like them, they go home, move, come out, et cetera. This way you can tap into markets you may not have available in your state, because I do know there are areas with few hygienists versus a lot.
So okay, let's say you've done all of this. You've gone through all these steps and advertised in other states. I'm going to say that 99% of the time, if you go through all this, you'll find as many hygienists as you need. You will find somebody, because you're being proactive, which not everybody is going to be.
But let's say some fluke occurs, and you just can't find a hygienist. You've done it all. Nothing. Do you do your own hygiene at that point? Well, no. Maybe temporarily. We get someone else to do it. Who else can do it? We get an associate doctor. In a few cases, and this isn't everywhere, I've seen hygiene ads offering up to $500, $600, or $700 a day. And when you dig into that and look at what associates get as a guaranteed per diem, in the Tampa Bay area, for instance, the average per diem is about $750 plus incentives. So you're almost at associate pay at that point.
And there are a couple of bonuses with this. Not that I'd want to do it as a permanent thing. If I hire a doctor, I want them to eventually be a doctor. But if I need somebody, and I can pay maybe a little more than I'd pay a hygienist, that does come with some benefits. They're a doctor, number one, and there's the supervision point. Under Florida's Board of Dentistry rules, and again, this is not legal advice, a hygienist can do prophies, X-rays, root planing, and sealants under general supervision. You authorize them, but you don't have to be in the building. But local anesthesia requires direct supervision, so they're not doing a lot of scaling and root planing if a patient needs a shot. The dentist has to be on site. So an associate solves that presence issue. If you need coverage, you need someone who's on call, and if you're paying maybe a little more than a hygienist and they're booked, that could work.
And here's what happens. As the office gets busier, because you have hygiene availability, more dentistry turns up. The associate maybe picks up some of the dentistry you don't want to do, maybe single crowns, molar endos, et cetera, and then you fill hygiene with another part-time hygienist, maybe a temp, or another associate. That's a solution. Obviously, long term it's going to be less expensive to get a hygienist. But if I can't find one, I wouldn't just stop and go, "I'm hopeless. I'm sunk. Nothing's going to work." I'd bring in an associate at that point.
A few more options. A shorter-term one is part-timers. I'm not necessarily against this. If I have four days of hygiene I need to fill, and I have somebody willing to give me two and two people who'll give me one each, and they're consistent, I'll do it. You could probably even work out coverage in there sometimes. Susie, your one-day-a-week hygienist, can't make it three weeks from now, and your other one-day-a-week hygienist can take that spot. That's always an option.
I'm not against having a part-time hygienist. I think it's fine. But they have to be part of the team, and obviously they have to meet your hiring criteria. It has to work for you. You have to be happy with their clinical performance. If part of the job is helping with the treatment presentation or acceptance process, pointing things out to patients, patient education, or hygiene instruction, they need to be able to do these things. I wouldn't settle for somebody who tells you, "Well, I don't like doing that, so I'm not going to do it." That doesn't work, because ultimately they're still an employee. They're still part of the team.
Longer term, I've seen some offices that are looking at long-term expansion sponsor an assistant or two through hygiene school. It's a bit of a longer play, but schools are growing. First-year enrollment is up 16%. That's another source of potential future hygienists. You could look at upcoming graduates, get in with the local hygiene program, and make sure you're on the list for potential hygienists when they get licensed.
So if you go through all of this, it would be extraordinarily difficult not to have a hygienist. There's no reason not to have one. And having no hygienist when you need one just doesn't work. A doctor who's really cranking can produce $1,000 to $2,000 an hour. A hygienist who's killing it is maybe doing $300 to $400 an hour, or less if you have managed care. And while those are high-performer numbers, even if you run the ADA's own figures for average billings and clinical hours, the average GP comes out to around $460 to $660 per clinical hour. Either way, every hour you spend doing a prophy, you're trading a doctor hour for a hygiene hour. It's just not good for the practice.
Here's what I'd leave you with. If I'm evaluating a dental practice, what's a major statistic I look at to see if the practice is actually growing? If you've listened for a while, you know the number I'm looking for: the number of recall visits. If I'm looking at how many recall visits they have in a week or a month, and that number isn't growing, that tells me the practice, since they're getting new patients, is not retaining patients.
Because if you think about it, for every new patient you add, you add at least two additional hygiene visits per year if they're on six-month recall, and more if they're on three- or four-month recall. So if you add 100 new patients, that's 200 or more hygiene visits per year. So the number of recall patients should always be growing. If it's not, something is wrong.
And this is where you can get snookered into thinking you don't have a problem when you actually do, especially if you run new patient initial appointments through hygiene. Obviously, you're doing the exam. I'm fine with doing new patient initials through hygiene. I don't have a problem with it. They can do the charting and the imaging or whatever. The only problem is that you're taking a hygiene slot. For most of us, if you're paying a hygienist $60 or $65 an hour, the last thing you want to see is them with no patients. That's maddening. So as long as hygiene has a patient in it, most people don't pay attention. "Oh yeah, the hygienist is booked. They have the occasional cancellation or no-show. No big deal."
Don't think that way. Your hygiene department should be growing. If you're adding 25 to 30 new patients per month, you should be adding one day of hygiene per week per year. I'll say that again. If you're doing 25 to 30 new patients a month, you should be adding an additional day of weekly hygiene per year. So if I had four days this year, and I got 25 to 30 new patients a month, I should have five days next year, and six days the year after, if I keep those new patients steady. If that's not happening, and it only looks fine because the slots are filled, a lot of your patients are not being retained, which is a humongous problem, because it throws the whole business cycle out.
You're essentially acting like a specialist. Not that I'm dogging specialists, but that's the specialist business model. If I'm an endodontist, I'm living off new patients. That's how it works. I don't have a recall system or patients coming in for hygiene appointments. But if you're a general dentist, hygiene is your built-in retention mechanism, and that is your growth statistic. It's also where future dentistry gets diagnosed, and it's how you keep patients coming in so they can maintain their oral health. So that's a number I would keep a sharp eye on. And if you have no hygienist, or you're doing all your hygiene yourself, you're not even going to be close to looking at that. It's just not going to work.
Anyway, I think I came in at the 30-minute mark, or close to it. I do hope this helps. If you have any questions, you can always email me at jeffb@mgeonline.com. You can also find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. Folks, find that hygienist, have a great week, and we'll see you at the next episode.