Have you ever looked at your treatment schedule for tomorrow, and seen a name that makes you just not want to come in to work? Does this patient make it difficult for your staff? In this week's episode, Jeff goes over how to handle a patient that might not be working out with your practice.
Links:
The MGE Communication & Sales Seminars - https://www.mgeonline.com/mge-communication-and-sales-seminars/
The MGE New Patient Workshop - https://www.newpatients.net/
Listen to full episode :
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
Do dentists have to treat every patient who comes in?
Jeff doesn't believe so, though he notes he isn't giving legal advice. He suggests getting very familiar with the dental practice act where you practice. Many dentists keep treating difficult patients out of a sense of obligation, but he recommends liking yourself enough to only have patients in your practice that you actually like, the way MGE won't keep working with a client who's a problem.
Why do toxic patients cause so much stress in a dental practice?
It's simple math. If 10% of people are toxic, a practice with 10 staff has one problem employee, but a practice seeing 20 to 30 patients a day over a four-day week could have eight to 12 problem patients every week. Their effect is bigger than it seems: the team focuses on the one jerk instead of the 19 grateful patients, staff get upset, and doctors sometimes change approaches that were working just to please one person.
How can you tell if a patient is a problem patient?
Look for the anomaly. Most patients react in normal ways: a billing mistake upsets them, you sort it out, and they're fine. A problem patient's reaction is outsized and never resolves, or they ask for something unusual, like wanting to change your consent form, refusing to sign it, or asking you to bill their spouse's insurance to cover their copay. Compared against the thousands of patients you've seen, they don't match up.
How should you handle a patient who is rude to your staff?
Confront it, and have the doctor or office manager do it, not the staff member. Talk to the patient, tell them what you heard, and watch whether they own up to their behavior. Everyone has bad days, and some will apologize. Jeff says a new patient who complains about a front desk person who's been with you 10 years is most likely the problem. If you don't protect your team, you create a toxic workplace and eventually lose good staff.
What should you do before dismissing a dental patient?
Follow the dental practice act where you practice to the letter, so you don't open the door to an abandonment claim. Jeff recommends calling your attorney or malpractice carrier first. Carriers are often happy to help, since you're averting a claim. It gets complicated if you're mid-treatment and may have to finish the work, which is why it pays to spot red flags early, before treatment starts.
Episode Transcript
-
Have you ever looked at tomorrow's schedule and seen a name that made you not want to come to work? I think you know what I'm talking about. That patient who's rude, unappreciative, and tough on your staff. Whenever they come into the practice, the team gets agitated. Things start to go wrong.
You can't wait until you're done. Then the front desk talks about the latest insult they had to endure, and heaven forbid you did any major work on them, because they'll be back later that afternoon to complain about it, and maybe about some other dental work you did or didn't do. Well, if you have a patient, or more likely several patients, like this, I have a question.
Why are you treating them? When I ask a dentist this question, I often find the answer comes from a sense of obligation, a duty as a healthcare provider, if you will. But maybe I missed something. Does the dental practice act where you practice state that you have to treat everybody who comes through your door?
I'm not giving out legal advice here, but I'm pretty sure it doesn't, and if you don't know, I recommend you get really familiar with it. And on a somewhat disconnected note, but related to this: when you survey doctors about their biggest source of stress or problems, staff usually comes up as one of the top one or two answers, if not the number one answer.
And it's not just training staff or finding staff. In some cases, it's problem staff or nonperforming staff. I've seen staff issues attributed as the top reason for the burnout dentists experience in some cases. And of course, problem or toxic staff do exist.
But simple mathematics tells you that you have a far better chance of having problem or toxic patients. Think about it. How many staff do you have? Let's say you have 10 staff, and let's take a random percentage of people who are going to be toxic. There's an actual percentage we go over in one of our seminars, but for argument's sake, let's say it's 10%. With 10 staff, that means one person is a problem.
One person is toxic. But let's look at your patients for a second. How many patients do you see in an average day? I'm not just talking about you as the doctor, but the entire practice. Twenty or 30? Now do that over a four-day week. That's 80 to 120 patients. If we take that 10% number again, that means eight to 12 of the people in your practice were a problem that week.
Not for the month or the year. I'm talking about that week. My point is that the problems you have with stress, burnout, negative commotion, et cetera, in your practice more often than not relate back to something going on with your patients, not your staff. Now, your staff, negatively affected by these people, might then also become problematic, but if that's the case, it originated with one or more of these patients.
And that's what I want to talk about in this week's episode: problem or toxic patients, and how to handle them to create a less stressful environment and a more productive practice. My name is Jeff Blumberg, and I'm your host. And I should start off by pointing out that the effects of this problem or toxic patient issue are a lot bigger than you might conceive of, especially the knock-on effects or ramifications. If it's not handled correctly, it can create a far less productive office that's less fun and potentially toxic in and of itself as an environment. And for that matter, you may or may not have heard of the MGE Communication and Sales Seminars.
This isn't just to self-promote. There's a reason I'm saying this, although the self-promotion doesn't hurt. The MGE Communication and Sales Seminars are three three-day seminars that we do here in Florida, in the St. Petersburg area. We also stream them, so you can attend either way, although I recommend you come in person if you can.
They're basically to teach you how to get your patients to want what they need. And they're very effective. The average doctor attending sees a $288,000 increase in the first year. They're very, very good. But believe it or not, one and a half days of those nine days are dedicated to teaching people how to detect toxic or problem patients or people. That's one and a half days of the training, and you might ask why we'd do that in a sales seminar. I teach that section of the seminar, and I often joke when I stand up, because many people come into the Communication and Sales Seminars from the MGE New Patient Workshop. Self-promotion again, or company promotion, at least.
I'll put a link to both these seminar types on the episode webpage. But they'll come from the New Patient Workshop, which is about how to get more patients. And let's say they're attending this seminar as their first of the three, because you can attend them in any sequence. On their first day, they're learning how to get rid of patients.
It's a bit counterintuitive, and it's a little funny, but it is extremely important. Obviously, there are a lot of characteristics you're looking for when you're evaluating this person. Are they a problem? Is it something that could be handled, or is it something where you might have to part ways?
Obviously I can't get into all of that in a podcast, but what I do plan to cover in this episode is what an interaction with a patient that's probably not going to work might look like. What are some signs that you might have a problem? I want to go over what to do about it, how to protect your team, and when it's time to dismiss this patient and move on, and some things to think about with relation to dismissal. So what might this look like? There really isn't one size fits all in this case. You know when you might have a problem. There are lots of examples. You have a patient who sees your hygienist, and your hygienist walks out of the room crying because the patient was really rude and nasty to them.
Or you have a new patient who sits down with you and complains about how horrible your front desk person is and how they treated them like garbage, even though you know your front desk is awesome and has been with you for 10 years. Or you have a patient where you need to get down to explaining their treatment plan and how much it's going to cost, and then they start getting into how they want you to not take a copay, or they want you to treat them and pretend you're also treating their spouse, who's also on their plan, so that you can collect insurance from her, and therefore you're made whole and they don't have to pay their copayment, right? It can look any way. You might be explaining the treatment plan to a patient, and maybe you get into how much it costs, and then they stop you and tell you something like, "Doctor, let me explain something to you.
"I've trained a lot of people how to sell, and a lot of patients would find what you're doing to be not very nice or unengaging, or it would make them uncomfortable. They probably don't tell you, but I'm the most honest person I know. So let me tell you that what you're doing is wrong, and you need to tone things down a bit."
It could come in any number of ways, right? But the bottom line is, and this is where it gets a bit weird, so I'm trying to think of the best way to explain it, that what you're looking for here is really the anomaly. You treat a lot of patients in a given week, month, year, et cetera.
So there are certain ways people are going to react to different things. Say there's a mistake on a patient's account. They might be slightly miffed or upset. You sort it out, it resolves, and they're fine, right? That's the norm. But then there's that one patient. You try to resolve the issue, and they just don't trust you. You're just out to get their money.
It just does not resolve, no matter what you do. It's weird. And the funny thing about human nature, and I don't know if this is a human nature point, it's just something I've observed, is this: you've seen 20 patients in a day, and 19 of them are any mix of grateful, appreciative, or just nice. But there's one person who's just a complete jerk, and who is everybody thinking and talking about at the end of the day?
It's that one person. That's the one you're talking to your significant other about. That's the one the front desk is talking to each other about. That one person who just wasn't very nice, as opposed to the 19 who really appreciated you and really liked that you were there.
Everybody's focused on that one negative guy or girl. And because of this human nature, again, I don't know if it is, it's just something I've observed, let's take that example where you're presenting a treatment plan to somebody. It's the same way you've presented treatment before, it's worked, patients pay, patients are happy, and so on, and they're telling you your approach is wrong.
Well, we don't want to have somebody upset or make them uncomfortable. So let's say this was working. You've done this for weeks or months, and your close rate on cases is pretty high. Then this one person comes along and tells you to tone things down, and that you shouldn't talk about finances, because that makes you look like you're just interested in their pocketbook, et cetera.
And you go, "Oh my gosh, I can't believe I did that. I feel really bad. I'll just tone it down and stop doing that." Then you notice, because you changed for this one person, even though what you were doing had been working for months and months and months, that your close rate goes down, because you didn't want to make that one person uncomfortable by doing what you normally do.
So I guess the best way of explaining this is that you're looking for the anomaly, where the reaction is just outsized. It doesn't make any sense. The person slamming the front desk because you charged them $5 too much, or you said their insurance would pay X and it didn't. It's just unusual. It's the anomaly.
They're asking you to do something really weird. That, to me, is always a humongous red flag, because if you compare it against the thousands of other people you've seen, you'll start to see that they don't match up. You probably have patients sign consent forms. I hope you do.
Have you ever had a patient ask to change the consent form? Did you? I hope you didn't, because why do you have those consent forms? To protect you. And what you'll notice is that everybody signs them, but then there's that one person who wants to change it or doesn't want to sign it. That person may be your problem.
Do you see? So the problem with these patients is that when they come into your practice, they create issues, they upset the staff, they're rude and unappreciative, or whatever. You have to look at the effect that's having on you, the rest of your team, and the practice as a whole. How does that interaction affect you with the next patient?
Does it make you feel better, or does it make you feel worse? Are you more or less effective with that next patient? Do you see? The reason I'm bringing this up is that you have to look at whether this person should actually be in your practice. There has to come a point where you're going to have to confront this issue.
And here's the difference. If you have a problematic or toxic staff member, some people do drag their feet on it, but it's usually not a big, huge decision: "I need to move on from Jane or Joe, or whomever it is, and get somebody in there to replace them."
Why? Because you're paying that person to be there, and it's not working out. But with patients, there's this idea of obligation that comes in. You don't want to dismiss patients. And there are a lot of weird ideas in business you can get focused on, like "the customer is always right." But how is the patient who's tearing up your front desk right?
Or the one treating your hygienist like garbage? Or someone who's rude to you? In dentistry, and actually in a lot of businesses, the patient isn't always right. The patient should be treated with care and courtesy, but they're not always right. If I come to you and I want a multi-pin restoration instead of a crown, does that make me right?
A multi-pin amalgam restoration? No. Just because it's what I want to do doesn't make me right. It doesn't necessarily make me a problem either. I could just be uneducated. But the point is that the patient isn't always right. And then there's that idea we get into: "We can't lose customers. The patient's always right. I need butts in the seats."
That's a bad frame of mind to be in when you're running a business, because you're going to end up having people as customers that you don't want as customers. You're going to abide people you wouldn't normally abide in your day-to-day life. And that's something I'd recommend you don't do. Like yourself enough to only have patients in your practice that you actually like.
We do that at MGE. If we have a client who's a problem, we just don't work with them. There are other companies they can go work with. And you might say, "Well, gosh, Jeff, you're giving away fees. You're giving away finance." I don't care. I want to be able to wake up, look at myself in the mirror in the morning, and actually want to go to work.
Shouldn't you be the same way? And here's the funny thing that happens when your focus is "I have to keep patients." I'm not saying you should get rid of good patients. But if your focus is "I have to keep patients, no matter how terrible it is to deal with this person," then what are you really focusing on?
What are you afraid of? What are you worried about? Your focus goes onto finance, or the fee, and that's the last place you want to be as a healthcare professional. Have you ever been sold by somebody you knew just wanted your money? You can almost feel it. You never want to be there. You don't want to be the effect of a patient's fee.
You have to actually want to help this person and want to treat this person. If they're willing to work with you, great. If they're a problem, then fine, you probably need to move on. So what do you do if you have a problem patient, or you suspect one? Remember, we have our baseline, which is normal. That's where the hundreds, if not thousands, of your patients fall. They're all over the place as people.
Some are upbeat, and some are not, but generally they do what they're supposed to do. They miss an appointment once in a while, but they pay their bill. Maybe they get a little aggravated when something goes wrong or if they have to wait, but they're pretty normal. What do you do when you get that anomaly?
Well, the first thing you have to be willing to do is confront it. And specifically, the way I would do this is not to have your whole team confronting issues like this. Let's take the example I brought up earlier: a person trashes your hygienist, and your hygienist walks out of the operatory in tears.
What should you do? Again, you have to do what you want to do, but I'm giving you what I would recommend to a client. I would recommend that they go talk to that patient, maybe with the office manager if they feel more comfortable having a witness there, or by themselves, and say, "Hey, listen, I was just talking to my hygienist, Susie, and she said she was pretty upset after interacting with you." And I'm going to watch how they react.
Because you know what? Everybody can have a bad day. That happens. And in some cases, the person at that point might own it. That's what I'm looking for. Do they own their behavior? "Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry, Doctor. I'm just having a terrible day. I just got some really bad news at work, and I took it out on her. I'm so sorry. Can I apologize to her?"
I had a client do this. They talked to the patient, in just the example I've given you, and the person apologized to the hygienist. The next day, the person came in with a big teddy bear and flowers for the hygienist. The person attempted to take responsibility for what they did.
Or you have the patient who's demanding that you commit insurance fraud. Just tell them, "Look, that's insurance fraud. I can't do that." And if they say, "Well, if you're not going to do that, I'm not willing to be a patient here," good. You don't want to deal with insurance fraud. You get my point.
Does the person own it? Or maybe they didn't know it was insurance fraud: "Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry. Okay, well then fine. I have to figure out how I'm going to pay this copayment." That's what we're looking for, but we have to be willing to confront it from the get-go. There are a couple of things that happen when you do that, and there's a thing that happens if you don't.
Let's say I have a patient who comes into the office and is just really rude and mean to the staff. Let's say it's a new patient. They come in and treat the front desk like trash. They come back to you as the doctor and say, "Hey, Doctor, I've heard a lot of good things about you, but that person you have up at the front is a real problem.
"I walked in, and she was very rude to me. She told me to sit as if I was a dog. I've never been treated so disgracefully in my life," and blah, blah, blah. Well, the wrong thing to do at that point is to go along with it because you're in the frame of mind that the patient's always right and we can't mistreat the customer. And I agree, you shouldn't mistreat the customer. But let's take a look at this for a second. This is a new patient. My front desk has been with me for 10 years. Who's most likely the problem? It's most likely the new patient. The front desk gets the benefit of the doubt. The front desk is also my staff member.
I've worked with them for 10 years, and we've been through a lot together, so I'm going to trust the staff member first. So I'm just going to tell you how I'd handle this. Whether you'd want to handle it this way is up to you. At that point, I'd probably say, "Okay, good.
"Well, what happened? Okay. Well, that's very uncharacteristic of how that interaction normally happens in the office. Give me a minute." Go talk to your front desk for a second: "I don't know what happened. He was just really mean, rude," et cetera, blah, blah, blah. Go back: "I was just talking to Samantha up there, and she said you were kind of rude when you came in.
"Do you mind if I put you two together and see if we can sort this out?" "Oh, well, no. I don't want to deal with that," blah, blah, blah. "You know what? Maybe this just isn't a good fit for you, and you might want to move on." In other words, I'm creating an environment that's comfortable for my staff. Because if I don't protect my staff from that, if I don't go talk to the rude patient who just tore up the hygienist and I let patients come in and run amok in the practice, my staff are going to get dinged up. They're going to get beaten up. And if they see that I'm going to do nothing about it and just let people come in and beat them up, I'm creating a toxic work environment, and work is going to be a drag. They're not going to want to come to work, and eventually I'm going to lose good staff.
And they're also going to know that I'm not protecting them, whether it's you or the office manager doing this. In some cases it may be better coming from the doctor. In some cases the office manager might be appropriate. But someone has to do this, and it should not be the staff member. I would not want the hygienist having to confront this on their own. You know what I want the hygienist doing? Being super productive and doing great care on my patients. That's what I want. I want them taking care of my patients. That's what they should focus on. I want my schedulers focusing on scheduling, and I want my receptionist answering the phone and making patients feel really welcome. I don't want them handling disgruntled, upset, or problem patients.
I'll handle that, or the manager will handle that, because if I let it float all over the organization, that creates problems. And staff should know that if they have a problem patient, the office manager gets called right away, and the office manager can discern whether it should be them or the doctor talking to this patient, to pull them off the line, so to speak.
Sort of like in the old days, when you'd see a cane come out from the side of the stage and yank somebody off. Same thing. Pull them off the line, bring them to an office: "Hey, what's going on?" blah, blah, blah. "Let's see if we can sort this out or not." But the main thing I'm looking for when I'm having this conversation, and this is the same thing that would happen at MGE if someone came in who started trashing people, was being disruptive, or was upsetting other clients... It used to be me having this conversation.
Now we have other people in the company who have it, but the conversation would be, "Hey, I have a report that this, this, this, and this happened," and then see if they own it. "Well, yeah. Sorry. Look, can I apologize?" Great. Or, "Look, I'm the customer. You need to treat me right,"
blah, blah, blah. "You know what? This isn't a good fit for you. You need to move on, because I don't want that type of stuff in my environment." So you have to be willing to confront these things, not only for your own mood and for the safety and comfort of your practice, but also to protect your team from getting beat up.
So now let's say you've done this. You've talked to the patient, and they're just a problem. And look, there could be other things where maybe they're not necessarily toxic. Let's say it's somebody who's failed six appointments in a row, and they're just a problem, because that starts to create all kinds of problems in the practice.
And you've decided, "You know what? I'm done. I just want to dismiss this patient." Well, then you should dismiss the patient. But there are a few things you'll probably want to keep in mind. Number one is the dental practice act where you practice. You want to follow the dental practice act to the letter of the law.
You don't want to open the door to the potential for abandonment or anything like that. Here's what I'd recommend, and I've told clients to do this: talk to your attorney, or talk to your malpractice carrier. I've seen clients call their malpractice carrier and say, "Hey, I've got this patient I want to dismiss. I just want to make sure I'm doing it right."
In some cases, the malpractice carrier was happy to hear from the doctor, because it wasn't about a claim. They were averting a claim, and they were happy to give advice. Or you can talk to your lawyer. But you want to make sure that you observe the dental practice act to the letter when you're letting go of a patient, because you don't want to open the door to any type of blowback.
Now, where this can become complicated is if you're in the middle of treating this patient. This is why you want to be able to detect these patients early, during their early interactions, and confront it early. If you're mid-work, again, that's a question for an attorney or the malpractice carrier.
In many cases, you're going to have to complete that work. Again, I'm not giving advice in that sense. I'm not an attorney, and I'm not a malpractice insurance carrier. But you want to make sure you don't set yourself up for further blowback from this patient, and you want to do everything in your power to move them along as quickly as legally possible, so that you don't open yourself up to further attack.
But the point is, in a lot of cases, and I've seen this, these things go south and the doctor ends up in the middle of treatment, and now they have a problem. They saw the red flags early on. They knew this person was a problem, and had they just followed their instincts and moved on from that patient, they never would have ended up in trouble.
All they'd done by that point was take X-rays. The second they started treating that patient was when they got themselves in trouble. But they knew. They knew in their heart that they shouldn't be doing it. So that's the key. Before you get into it, if you feel like something's just off, that this just isn't right, don't do it. You might think it's going to cost you money, patients, revenue, et cetera.
It really won't. The quicker you move on, the better. You're creating a more positive environment, not only for yourself and your staff, but also for your other patients and the interactions you and your staff are now going to have with them, because you're focusing on patients who are actually happy to see you and appreciate that you're there.
So, a shorter episode this week. Just keep in mind: keep your environment pleasant and free from this type of drama, and you'll find the office is a lot more productive. You don't owe your help to anyone. Treat people you actually want to treat, people you care about.
It's your practice, and it's your career. I could say the same thing for your team. Make it fun, and make it worthwhile. I hope this helps. If you have any questions, you can always email me directly at jeffb@mgeonline.com, and I have the links to the MGE New Patient Workshop and the Communication and Sales Seminars on the episode webpage.
And if you want more info about us, you can find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. Folks, have a great week, and we'll see you at the next episode.