Is your staff struggling with all the duties in each area of your business? In this week’s episode, Jeff goes over strategies of handling the office’s workload so that the practice can thrive productively.
Links:
Download the Hygiene Formula - https://www.mgeonline.com/hygieneformula/
Free PPO Exit Strategy Session - https://www.mgeonline.com/ppo-exit-strategy
Podcast Episode 98 - Cycle of Booms and Depressions - Ep. 98: The Cycle of Booms & Depressions (youtube.com)
Listen to full episode :
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
Why does the overstaffed or understaffed question usually involve the front desk?
Jeff says it comes down to familiarity. Most doctors understand the workload of the dental assistants, hygienists, and associates because they could do those jobs themselves. They are far less familiar with what is involved at the front desk, so they tend to notice problems only when holes appear in the schedule.
What are incoming and outgoing traffic, and why do they matter?
Every position has both. Incoming traffic is patients calling, checking in, and checking out. Outgoing traffic is reaching out to patients, such as recall calls, follow-ups, and reactivation. When a position is so busy with incoming traffic that it has no time for outgoing traffic, the schedule empties out, which leads to the ups and downs Jeff calls the cycle of booms and depressions.
How can a practice with 4,000 charts be understaffed and not need more staff yet?
Jeff's example is a one-doctor office with one hygienist and 4,000 charts. Even after allowing for 40% of recalls being hard to get back in, the math points to about 96 recall appointments a week, or 12 days of hygiene, so the office could support three or four hygienists. The real problem is that no one has time to call those patients in. He suggests adding someone to do outreach first, then staffing as the practice grows.
What should a treatment coordinator be doing when not in a presentation?
Following up on recent presentations that did not close, then working through the incomplete treatment list. Jeff says calling to ask if a patient wants the treatment rarely works, so he suggests getting them back on the hygiene schedule or in for a doctor check, which creates a new chance to present the treatment. A coordinator in five or six presentations a day has little time left for this.
What percentage of revenue should go to staff payroll, and how do PPOs affect it?
Jeff says staff payroll should not exceed 22.5% of revenue including payroll taxes, excluding the doctor owner and associates. In Canada or elsewhere outside the United States he gives 20.9%, not including employer payroll taxes. PPO fees can distort the percentage: $30,000 in payroll is 20% of $150,000 at full fee but 30% of $100,000 at PPO fees, so the practice can look overstaffed when it is really undercharging. MGE offers a free PPO Exit Strategy Session.
Episode Transcript
-
Am I overstaffed? Am I understaffed? How many staff should I actually have? I get these questions, or variations of them, quite a bit. Of course, my answer really depends on the given situation. But that said, when I'm asked this question, there are a few specific things I check in every instance that I felt would be worth sharing.
If the idea of staff complement has been on your mind and you're trying to figure out where you stand, then for this week's episode, we're going to look at a few tips on how to determine the proper staff complement for your practice, so that you can answer that overstaffed, understaffed question for yourself. My name is Jeff Blumberg and I'm your host, and I think the best place to start is by looking at why this even becomes a question and what area of a dental practice it normally pertains to.
Generally speaking, when I get a question like this, it relates more often than not to administrative staffing, the front desk. Very rarely does it have to do with the back office, meaning associates, hygienists, and so on. Why? One word: familiarity. If you're the average doctor, you are intimately familiar with what happens in the back office. You have a deep understanding of what the workload would be for your dental assistants, your associate, your hygienist, and so on. So you don't really have a big question about whether you need more or less staff, because, one, you could pretty much do all of the jobs that people are doing in the back, and two, even if there are cases where you could do it faster, you have some idea of what an acceptable level of speed is for an employee in these areas, and therefore you can accurately determine what the actual workload is.
So usually there's no problem determining whether you're over or understaffed in the back office. There is one exception, though, and it's a bit of a roundabout way of explaining it. Let's say it's you, one hygienist, and two dental assistants in the back, but your practice has 4,000 charts. In theory, if you take those 4,000 charts, you should have at least three, if not more, hygienists. I'll explain why. I've covered this on the program before, but in brief, this is usually a big area of lost opportunity.
If you have 4,000 charts, that equates to at least 8,000 recall appointments a year. That's just with six-month recall. Now let's say 40% of those are difficult to get back in, which is fairly conservative. It's a large number, right? So 40% of these 8,000 recalls, that's 3,200, you have trouble getting in. That leaves you with 4,800 recalls a year with these 4,000 charts. If you have 4,800 recalls a year and you work 50 weeks a year, that's 96 recall appointments per week. I apologize for the math, especially if you're listening to this in the car, but it's pretty basic, and I'm about done with it. If you have 96 recall appointments a week, and the average hygienist can see eight patients a day, that is 12 days of hygiene per week, if you were at a decent level of compliance in your hygiene department.
You only have one hygienist. In theory, with those 12 days of hygiene, if you're open four days a week, you should have three hygienists, but you probably need more, because that doesn't account for scaling and root planings, or for running new patients through hygiene. So you might end up needing four hygienists. We took this one-doctor office with one hygienist, and they really need four, if they were at decent compliance, not even maximum. And if you had four hygienists, or even three and a half, there's a really good chance you're going to need an associate doctor. You're going to be too busy. You can't spend your entire day being the hygiene check doctor. Most likely, the amount of traffic that creates in the practice is going to require probably another full-time associate.
So in theory, with that 4,000-chart office, you technically are understaffed, but based on your current iteration, you're really not, because of the amount of traffic coming into the practice, if that makes sense. I wouldn't go out and hire all those people yet. What I would do instead is dial back a bit and ask, why are those 4,000 patients not all coming in? That actually leads to the real problem with this whole under or overstaffed issue. The reason they're not coming in is: who is supposed to call those 4,000 patients in? Think about it for a second. It's your front desk, your administrative staff. That's why those 4,000 patients aren't there. Your dental assistants aren't going to call them, your associate's not going to call them (which you don't have in this iteration), and your hygienist is not going to call them. It's the front desk.
And here's where we run into unfamiliarity, normally on the part of the doctor. Like I said, this is where I tend to get the most questions. Why? Because the doctor doesn't really understand what's actually involved in running the front desk. You go up there and you see people calling people and scheduling people, and usually where we lose it is when we see somebody dealing with insurance, because nobody wants to look at that, so we just walk away at that point. We notice it when there are holes in the schedule. That's when we get really interested in the front desk. But if you think about it, if things were rolling along smoothly, you would hardly ever walk up there except to say hi to your team members.
That's a bit of a problem for a business owner. If you are only familiar with one area of your business, the area you're not familiar with is the area that can potentially hurt you. So the first thing to understand, if you really want to understand what's happening at your front desk and what the workload is, and you could apply this to any position, is this: every position has two types of traffic, incoming traffic and outgoing traffic. If I'm a scheduler, I'm calling people on the phone. That's outgoing traffic. Then I'm handling patients when they're in the practice, or patients are calling me to schedule appointments. That's incoming traffic. You can look at any position and it has incoming and outgoing traffic.
What can happen is that the position handles all the incoming traffic and has zero time for the outgoing traffic. Take that busy office, and let's say your administrative staff in the example I'm giving here is an office manager. You've got the one doctor, one hygienist, and two dental assistants in the back. At the front, we have an office manager who also acts as the treatment coordinator and the financial coordinator. So they're doing all the insurance verification, filing insurance, sorting accounts, and all that type of thing, as well as sitting in with you during treatment presentations, as well as being the office manager. And then we have another person who's answering the phone and scheduling patients. So we have two people up at the front, an office manager and a receptionist slash scheduler. You could walk up there and they seem sort of busy, but all they're handling is incoming traffic: patients calling into the practice, rescheduling patients, handling inquiries from patients, dealing with insurance traffic, and so on.
What happens in a situation like that, where those positions have no time for outgoing traffic, is you get these ups and downs in the practice. As a matter of fact, I talked about this in an episode a while back called The Cycle of Booms and Depressions. I'd recommend you check it out. I don't have the episode number in front of me, but if you search the list of previous episodes, you'll find it. That's when you get it, because essentially what's happening is the people at the front are just handling whoever is calling in. So what's the result? I'm handling incoming traffic and I don't have time to do any outgoing calls because it's so crazy busy, and I'm checking patients out and this and that. Then the schedule starts to empty out, and there are no patients there. What do I do? I get on the phone and start calling people again. You get the flow here. If you have positions where all they can do is deal with the incoming traffic and they don't have time to get into outgoing traffic, you're going to run into problems.
Hence, in this example, they have 4,000 charts, the majority of which are not active. They become inactive. For any chart, the longer you leave it with no communication, the more chance you have of that person never showing up again. This is a situation in most dental practices: a lot of effort is spent on getting the patient into the practice as a new patient and then presenting treatment. But then let's say I accept whatever treatment plan you present, you put me on the hygiene schedule, and I don't show up. There's very little follow-up done on me. The longer you let me drift into the ether, the less chance you have of recovering me. And the only reason I would be allowed to drift into the ether is that nobody has time to pick up the phone. In most cases, if someone actually had time to call me, they would call me. But in this scenario, that receptionist scheduler is too busy handling the new patient calls and the people who are there and helping check patients out. When the office manager is busy, and so on, they don't have time to call 4,000 patients.
So you have to look at every position from the perspective of what they are supposed to handle coming in and what they are supposed to do going out. I'll give you another example, the treatment coordinator. When we think of a treatment coordinator, this is somebody who's going to sit in with you during a treatment presentation and work out financial arrangements. I've talked about this at length before: you, the doctor, should be presenting how much the treatment plan costs, and the treatment coordinator can go off with them to figure out exactly how they're going to pay, get them to pay, do the financial application, and all that kind of jazz. But how many hours a day are they actually doing that? Probably not full time, and if they were, you probably need a second treatment coordinator. Here's why. Let's say I'm your treatment coordinator and I'm sitting in with you for four presentations a day. What am I supposed to do with the rest of my day?
I'm supposed to be calling patients to follow up on recent presentations that didn't close. Let's say we met with a patient last month and they said they really wanted to do the treatment plan, but they were refinancing their house and couldn't apply for credit right now, but the refinancing was supposed to close. (I guess in this day and age, as I'm recording this episode, refinancing is not the best idea, but whatever, they're refinancing their house.) I'm supposed to call and follow up, because that should have closed by now, so they can be ready to apply for credit. Then let's say I've done all the follow-ups I'm supposed to do for patients who didn't pay for a fairly valid reason. What should I be working on next when I'm not sitting in with you for a consultation?
I should be following up on other patients. You have a big old incomplete treatment list. Depending on the office, I've seen this list go into the millions. I should take that incomplete treatment list and call patients off it. Now, very often people will think, call these patients and see if they want to do the treatment. I probably wouldn't. You're always going to end up with an anomaly, but that is usually the exception, not the rule. Say you call the incomplete treatment list, and here's Bill, and you presented three crowns and an onlay the last time he was there, and he didn't accept. He was going to think about it. If I call Bill three months later, chances are Bill's not going to say, "Oh yeah, I'm glad you called. I decided to do the treatment plan." That happens from time to time, but it's very rare.
What would I do with Bill? If Bill is overdue for hygiene and I'm the treatment coordinator, I'm going to schedule him for hygiene, because I can get him back in, get him back in front of you as the doctor again, and then I'm there and we can present this treatment plan again. If Bill's not overdue for hygiene and you want to talk to Bill again, I might call Bill back in so you can have another look at his mouth and see if everything's staying stable. I'm creating more sales opportunities for both the doctor and myself as the treatment coordinator. But I have to have time for these follow-ups. If I'm doing eight or nine presentations a day and I don't have time for follow-ups and no one's calling them, they drift away. It's wasted opportunity. If you have a treatment coordinator sitting in for five or six presentations a day, that might eat up most of their day, and then they have a minimal amount of time for follow-up.
If you're going to understand any position, you have to understand how much time they should be spending on outgoing versus handling the incoming traffic. You have to examine it based on the individual situation. And whether you like it or not, if you own a business, you have to understand this. I'm not saying that as the doctor you have to understand all the anomalies and the missing tooth clause of X, Y, Z plan. You really don't. But you at least have to understand how the financial coordinator position works, how the treatment coordinator position works, and have an idea of their traffic flow and load.
What normally grabs the doctor's attention, or the office manager's attention in some cases, is when a position is not able to keep up with the general incoming traffic. For example, you walk by the front and see a receptionist on the phone with a new patient, and they have to put the new patient on hold because another phone is ringing. And then while they're talking, they put the person they're talking to on hold because another patient is now at the front trying to check out, and another patient at the same time is walking in to check in. That becomes painfully obvious. You realize you need to get him or her some help up there, or they're going to end up in trouble. They're going to blow off new patients, because new patients don't like being put on hold, and patients are going to wait, and so on. That becomes painfully obvious.
But we're not necessarily going to notice that this receptionist, who we also have scheduling patients, is not keeping up with the outgoing side. We'll notice when there are openings in the schedule, but we won't notice that there are a thousand people who are overdue for hygiene that they're not calling. So in order to properly understand a position, you have to understand its basic functions, not just the basic duties they're supposed to do when patients are inside the practice, but the outgoing communication that this position is supposed to have and stay on top of.
One thing I will mention, and I've offered this before: if you wonder how healthy your hygiene department is, how many hygiene patients, specifically recall patients, you should be seeing, you can download something we call the hygiene formula. It's a little spreadsheet. You enter a couple of numbers and it spits out a number telling you how many patients you should be seeing in hygiene. I'll put a link to it on the episode webpage if you want to check out how healthy your hygiene department is and how much room for growth you have.
To apply this, let's take a look at the scenario I've been painting: one doctor, one hygienist, two DAs, and a front desk person who's a receptionist scheduler. I have 4,000 inactive charts. We're assuming that my reception is just keeping up with current traffic, and my office manager is keeping up with current traffic. What would I do in this instance? Obviously they're keeping up with current traffic, but chances are they're not going to have time to stay on top of these 4,000 charts that are inactive, or 3,000 charts that are inactive. I probably need to hire somebody to actually reach out to those patients. Obviously I'm going to do more than phone calls. I'm going to do emails, texts, patient newsletters, postcards, and so on, to get these patients back on the schedule. But you probably need another set of hands at that point, because you don't have enough people to stay on top of your patient base. You just don't.
Then what will happen from there? We're going to staff as we expand. I don't want to overstaff to where I have somebody sitting around twiddling their thumbs. As the practice gets busier, now I've got a second hygienist. Now we're looking at adding a third. I might need an associate. I might need another dental assistant. I might need somebody else at the front. This is how I keep my practice properly staffed, because I don't want to get to the point where we're redlining, running to the point where we're about to burn the engine out because the current staff I have can't keep up with the incoming traffic, and not only can't keep up with the incoming traffic, they have no time for the outgoing traffic.
That's basically what I would look at. You have to analyze each position. Get an idea of what's actually involved with the position, not just the day-to-day duties in the practice, but the things this person should be doing to reach out to your patient base or reach outside of the office, and then look at their workload and see if they actually have enough time to do that. It's very easy to analyze how many calls are coming in a day, especially in this day and age, and how many responses we're getting from marketing, and so on.
That's another thing to think about. If all of a sudden I double or triple my marketing, unless my front desk was completely unbusy and I was looking at laying somebody off, there's a good chance I might have to add a staff member to keep up with that marketing traffic, because you start to dilute its effectiveness otherwise. Think about this for a second. If I'm getting six or seven new patient calls a day, which is not unusual, and then I do some marketing that really hits, and now I'm getting 20 or 30 new patient calls a day, on paper that sounds great. I get six or seven calls a day and we schedule five. That's pretty good. But now I'm getting 30 a day. Does the person who is answering the phone, or who is scheduling these new patient calls, have adequate time to effectively handle them? Probably not, based on their current workload.
Think about that. Say the average new patient call takes your practice seven or eight minutes. If they get seven calls a day, that's 56 minutes, call it an hour for ease's sake. If they get 30 calls, that's 240 minutes. That's four hours on the phone. They don't have the time. So what's going to happen is you're going to have this big win and then a big loss. You're going to see your new patient calls go through the roof and you're going to be all excited, but your new patients won't necessarily increase commensurately, because you've diluted the receptionist's ability to handle those calls the way they did when you were only getting six or seven.
So from a workload perspective, and this is just part of your executive hat, so to speak, you have to understand the position. You have to understand the incoming traffic this position handles and how much time it takes, as well as what's involved in the outgoing traffic. Then you'll be able to answer this question for yourself. This is why I can answer it: I listened to somebody explain it to me, and I thought, oh yeah, I get it, I can start to understand what's going wrong. These are all basic, common sense things.
For instance, let's say you have a bigger office. You have an office manager, somebody answering the phones, somebody scheduling patients, maybe even a part-time person doing reactivation, and a financial coordinator. Maybe it's two doctors and a few hygienists and some assistants. Again, let's paint this: office manager, part-time reactivation person, scheduler, receptionist, and a financial coordinator handling insurance. Due to the traffic coming into the practice, we're doing four or five treatment presentations a day between our two or three hygienists, our associate doctor, and myself. So who's the treatment coordinator? We let our financial coordinator present really small cases, say $2,000 or whatever, because they're not very good at selling. So most likely in that scenario, the office manager is being the treatment coordinator. This is not unusual at all. It's usually the last hat the office manager stops wearing, because the office manager usually can sell and has been with the practice the longest.
If the office manager is spending four, five, or six hours a day in case presentations, number one, they're not going to have time to actually be the office manager, which is a problem. And if you're an office manager listening to this, I have to warn you about this. In a sense, it's very glorious and fun to close these big cases. Everybody is excited about it. It's very valuable to the practice and very valuable to the patient. But ultimately, as the office manager, you're supposed to properly get people to do their jobs, not necessarily do them yourself, especially if traffic justifies hiring somebody else. In that case, you most likely need a treatment coordinator, because your office manager doesn't have time to do their normal job, and because they're spending four or five hours a day doing treatment presentations, they don't have the time to fully wear the treatment coordinator hat, which includes the outgoing action. Do you see?
Same thing with a scheduler. If I have a scheduler in this scenario and I have 5,000 or 6,000 charts and we really only have 1,000 or 2,000 active, I don't know that the scheduler is going to be able to keep two doctors and three hygienists busy and find time to call these thousands of inactive charts. They're probably not, which is why, in the scenario I painted, we have a part-time reactivation person. So it's a matter of distributing workload. Again, I know I keep saying this: you're looking at the incoming traffic coming into the business as well as the outgoing traffic this person should be engaging in.
Another way of looking at this, and it's a little bit unusual, whether you're under or overstaffed or whether there's something wrong with your staff complement, goes back to finance. I've talked about this before in a prior episode, but generally speaking, from an overhead perspective, your staff payroll should not exceed 22.5% of your revenues. If we're doing $100,000 a month, my staff payroll should not exceed, including payroll taxes, $22,500. That's not including the doctor owner or associate doctors, but it does include the office manager, hygienist, and so on.
Where this can get a bit murky is if I'm involved in a lot of PPOs or low-fee type plans. Work with me on this for a second. Let's say we do $100,000 a month at PPO fees. What would that be at full fee? Probably $150,000, in most cases maybe a little less, but I think it's safe to say that if you're in a lot of PPOs and you extrapolate that to your normal full fee, instead of that $880 PPO crown, it's a $1,500 crown, and then you look at what you would have produced or collected otherwise, it would probably be $150,000. So $100,000 at PPO fees, $150,000 at full fee. Let's say your payroll is $30,000. If I did $150,000 and collected $150,000 and my payroll is $30,000, that's great. I'm at 20%. But if I do $100,000 and my payroll is $30,000, that's 30%. That's because I'm accepting lowered fees.
The reason that happens is that there's nobody else accounting for the fact that you are accepting a reduced fee for your services. Your assistant isn't taking a 30 or 40% haircut on their hourly salary because you're working on a PPO patient. Your landlord doesn't charge you less. The power company doesn't charge you less. You don't get a cheaper crown because it's a PPO patient. The lab doesn't say, "Oh, it's a PPO patient, let me write 40% off." Nobody writes anything off except you. So this is where it can become problematic. You may think, wow, I'm overstaffed because I'm spending all this money on payroll. But in fact, what's actually happening is you're just not charging enough for your services, and that skews your payroll percentage.
So ultimately, the thing you've got to do is get out of these plans. I've said for years that we took a bit of a laissez-faire approach with clients: "Hey, you should really get out of PPOs, it'd be a good idea." Some did, and they had big wins. But since 2020 we've been pushing this very hard, because since March of 2020 the compounded inflation rate has been over 21%. That's the official number, which means it's probably wrong. It's probably a lot higher. And remember that the official number is an average of a bunch of things. Things like healthcare and telecom and education haven't gone up 21%, but gas and food and power all have gone up over 21%. So you're in a situation where costs are going up, and in a lot of cases, especially if you're involved in PPOs, they've reduced your reimbursement. You hit a point where something has to give, and that will screw up your overhead percentages, because in theory you produced $150,000, but you really didn't. You produced $100,000, because you're accepting lowered fees. You can't survive like this long term. It's not ideal. So my suggestion is to get out of the PPOs.
If you want help with that, or any assistance, we do offer a consultation called a PPO Exit Strategy Session. It's free. You don't have to do anything and there's no obligation, but we can point out what would be involved in getting out. I'll put a link to it on the episode webpage if you'd like to find out more and check it out.
One last point, before I forget to mention it. I said the staff payroll figure should be 22.5%, including payroll taxes and excluding the doctor and the associate, and that's in the United States. If you're outside the United States, in Canada or elsewhere, that payroll percentage should be 20.9%, not including employer payroll taxes. So if you're in Canada, it's 20.9% for the actual salaries, plus payroll taxes.
Anyway, that's some general insight. Those are the things I'm looking at or checking when I'm looking at how staffed somebody is. There are always egregious situations where you can see if someone's over or understaffed. I remember looking at one situation where it was the doctor and an assistant in the back, and they had an office manager and three front desk staff. I thought, what do these people even do all day? This makes no sense. They were obviously overstaffed at the front. I've seen the reverse too, where there are three doctors and six hygienists and six dental assistants and two people up front. They don't have enough people at the front, administratively, to actually support the technical staff. At that point, these people at the front looked like they were losing their minds. They looked stressed out of their minds just due to the incoming traffic. And what was worse was when they ended up with huge holes in the schedule. They looked terrible, because they just didn't have time to keep up with it all.
Those are the basic things I would look at, or that I'd recommend you look at. I know maybe that's a little bit too easy of an answer, but you have to understand how these positions at the front work. You have to understand the stuff they handle coming into the office, as well as the traffic when it's in the office, as well as what they're supposed to be doing with outgoing traffic to make sure the office stays busy. Anyway, I hope that helps. That's all I have for you this week. Don't forget, on the episode webpage I have that hygiene formula download, as well as a link to the PPO Exit Strategy Session. I definitely recommend you take advantage of it, because some of these PPOs take a while to get out of, so the sooner you start, the sooner you're done. If you have any questions about MGE or you'd like to find out more about us, you can find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. Folks, have a great week, and we'll see you the next episode.