Could your hygiene department be underperforming? Jeff, with special guest Sabri Blumberg, reveal the production benchmarks every hygienist should hit, the costly mistakes most offices make, and a free tool to fix it.
Episode 202 Handout - https://www.mgeonline.com/episode-202-downloads-form-page/
ABC Communication & Sales Seminars - https://www.mgeonline.com/abc
Email any questions for Sabri to Sabrib@mgeonline.com
Listen to full episode :
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
How much should a dental hygienist produce per day?
It depends on your fees, but Sabri gives national averages for an eight-hour day. In a 100% PPO practice, hygiene averages $1,200 to $1,500 a day, or about $150 to $187 an hour. In a 100% fee-for-service practice, it averages $2,000 to $2,500 a day, or about $250 to $312 an hour, and she has seen practices reach $3,500. Many practices she works with fall short of the average.
Why do hygiene departments fall short of their production numbers?
Sabri points to cancellations, schedule openings left by weak recall and reactivation, and scheduling every patient for an hour whatever their needs. But the biggest reason is undercharging: hygienists treat periodontal disease with limited scaling or gross debridement, then charge it out as a prophy to avoid the financial conversation. She sees this in about 80% of the practices she reviews.
Why should a dental practice have a written perio policy?
A doctor-written policy sets clear diagnostic criteria: for each condition, how it is diagnosed, how it is charged, what the treatment is, and how long to schedule. It takes the decision out of the hygienist's hands and makes the conversation easier. The hygienist explains the condition, the doctor confirms the diagnosis, and someone else handles the fee. Patients also learn that their home care has consequences, which tends to improve it.
What are the pros and cons of assisted hygiene?
In assisted hygiene, one hygienist works two columns with an assistant who seats patients, takes X-rays, and turns over rooms. It helps when hygienists are hard to find, or when you want one favorite hygienist to see everyone. The downsides: less hygienist time to discuss treatment, so dental sales suffer, no help on perio therapy, and a second operatory tied up. Sabri would hire two hygienists whenever she could find them.
Should your hygienist help present treatment plans?
Yes. Sabri says the hygienist usually spends more time with the patient than the doctor and is a key part of the sales team. Hygienists can't diagnose, but they can flag issues for the doctor, discuss already diagnosed treatment, and give rough costs. Role-play common objections together. She would not hire a hygienist who refuses to take part, just as she wouldn't hire an associate who won't discuss treatment with patients.
Episode Transcript
-
Jeff: How much should a dental hygienist produce per day, or per hour? And are you, in many cases, potentially undercharging for hygiene without even realizing it? These are the kinds of questions we get all the time from doctor owners, office managers, and even hygienists themselves.
So to answer them, I thought for this week's episode I'd bring on and interview Sabri Blumberg. If you've been listening to the podcast for a while, you'll be very familiar with Sabri. She's the Deputy Chief Operating Officer here at MGE and our senior technical authority. She's worked with thousands of practices, trained tons of staff, office managers, and hygienists, and built multimillion-dollar hygiene departments from the ground up. And as you can see, we have the same last name. We're married, so I have to get this interview right, folks. We've worked together for 30 years, and I don't want to get in trouble. So with that, let me welcome Sabri to the show. Sabri, welcome.
Sabri: Hi, Jeff.
Jeff: Okay, so for this week's episode, we're going to tackle the most common and important questions surrounding your overall hygiene department. Rather than read all the questions up front, I figure we should just go through them. I know the questions I'm going to ask, though not what you're going to say, and I really think this is one of those episodes that could change the way people think about their hygiene department. So whether they're a doctor, an office manager, or a hygienist, it's something they're not going to want to miss.
Sabri: Okay.
Jeff: All right, cool. I think we just jump into it.
Sabri: Sounds good.
Jeff: All right, first question. How much should a hygienist produce per day, or per hour?
Sabri: Okay, so that one is somewhat modified by where the practice is located, because of fees. Obviously, fees in Beverly Hills are going to be different from fees in Arkansas. But the national average for a 100% PPO practice is between $1,200 and $1,500 per day. That boils down to anywhere between $150 and $187 an hour.
Jeff: Okay. So if this office is 100% PPO, so they're taking reduced fees, sometimes a 50% haircut in certain cases, they should be averaging $150 to $187 an hour, you said?
Sabri: Correct. And I'm not even saying that's what they should be doing. I'm saying that's the national average. So $1,200 to $1,500 a day. But a lot of practices I see are not even meeting the national average, for different reasons.
Jeff: Okay. And what if they have zero PPOs? They're just 100% private.
Sabri: Okay, so now the fees totally change, and I know they'll vary. But on a regular eight-hour day, the national average is anywhere between $2,000 and $2,500 a day. But I've seen practices do $3,500 a day, depending on their fees, their perio philosophy, and what the hygienist is doing. Very often we have hygienists who are not using all the skills they could be using. So it really depends, but on a national average basis, it boils down to roughly $250 to $312 an hour.
Jeff: That's for a private practice, with private fees. So you're saying you're seeing a lot of clients who are 100% PPO and aren't meeting the $1,200 to $1,500 per day. Or, though most clients coming in new have some degree of network participation...
Sabri: Correct. Usually they average about 70% PPO.
Jeff: That makes sense. But you're seeing that they're not meeting the $1,200 to $1,500, or the $2,000 to $2,500 if they're 100% private. So why?
Sabri: There are different reasons. First of all, it could be cancellations. Seeing way too many of them, which is easily fixed with a good cancellation policy that's actually applied and implemented in the practice. Or it could be that their hygiene just isn't maximized, and there are openings because they don't have good reactivation or recall protocols. So the hygienist is not seeing as many patients as she or he could be seeing in a day.
Jeff: So basically, and we talked about the confirmation process on the podcast a few weeks ago, their confirmation process is garbage and they have a bunch of openings. So obviously that's going to affect overall productivity. Or when you say they're not maximized, do you mean they're getting more time for an appointment than they need?
Sabri: It could be different things. That is one of the reasons. What I meant when I said maximized is that their current patients are not hygiene compliant. So they have openings in their hygiene schedule that just never got filled.
Jeff: So it's not even a matter of cancellations. They're just not filled. It's just a big old gaping hole in the schedule.
Sabri: That's exactly right. But you brought up a really good point.
Jeff: You have that on the record, folks. I brought up a good point. This is now recorded for posterity. 2,000 years from now, archaeologists will find this. Anyway, go ahead.
Sabri: Jeff brought up a good point. The good point you brought up is that very often there's a robotic quality to scheduling hygiene. Everybody gets an hour, regardless of how many teeth the person has or their age. Children, for example. You shouldn't be scheduling an hour for a kid. More like 40 minutes, maybe. And if somebody only has a few teeth left, they're still getting cleanings, but why are you scheduling an hour for that? So scheduling each patient according to their particular needs allows you to see more patients in a day, and that can affect it as well.
Jeff: And one thing I've seen you point out, and the clients have corrected it, is a hygienist seeing a patient who really needs a gross debridement, but they're just going to do a good cleaning. I've seen you deal with this with a few clients, and it seems to be a real problem.
Sabri: This is actually the biggest reason people are not producing what they need to in hygiene. Let's assume the factors we talked about earlier are handled: we're scheduling properly, patients are confirmed properly, and they're showing up, so I have a full schedule. And you're still not meeting those numbers. So what is happening? Very often, when I look at those schedules and those charges, every single patient is charged out as a prophy, even new patients. And it is simply not reasonable that nobody in that practice has periodontal disease.
So that means one of two things. Either they're seeing the periodontal disease and just ignoring it and doing cleanings, which is not very common. I can think of one example, but that's rare. Far more common is that they're treating the disease. They're doing limited scaling, they're doing gross debridement, they're doing everything the patient needs, but they're charging it out as cleanings, because they can't have that financial conversation with the patient.
Jeff: Just to clarify: the patient really needs some type of mild periodontal therapy, no one's talking to the patient about it, and instead it's just charged out as a prophy?
Sabri: That's correct.
Jeff: So we're doing much more than a prophy. We're really doing a gross debridement or mild scaling. We're just not charging for it.
Sabri: Correct. And that creates two problems. First of all, the hygienist doesn't get to count the production of what they're really producing.
Jeff: They're actually producing it, just not counting it.
Sabri: That's correct. And at the same time, the patient is unaware of the condition they're in. Certain habits the patient has create the periodontal condition: not flossing properly, not sticking to their cleaning schedule, not brushing properly, or whatever. And we are not addressing those issues with the patient, and there is no consequence for the patient. So even if we bring it up, like, "Hey, you really need to floss a little better," it's "You're just going to clean my teeth again."
Jeff: They don't realize they've got a bigger problem now that they really have to address.
Sabri: Yes. They have no idea that their habit has a consequence, because there is no consequence to the patient. The only consequence is to the practice. And my philosophy has always been to inform the patient: "Hey, listen, this is the condition you have. On these three teeth, we're going to have to do limited scaling, because you have tartar under the gums." Explain to them what's going on and how it happened. "So what we're going to do today is explain exactly how this happened, what you need to be doing at home so it doesn't happen anymore, and the schedule you need to maintain. And at the same time, we're going to take care of it today. It's going to be a bit of an extra charge, because it isn't a normal cleaning today. But if we take care of it today and you change your home habits, hopefully we won't have to do this again in the future."
So the patient becomes aware that the way they're treating their gums and teeth is creating a non-optimum condition. There's a consequence, they have to pay for it, but it also changes their habits, so hopefully the patient doesn't have to go through this again in the future.
Jeff: Which brings up a follow-up question, because this is interesting. You obviously talk to clients all the time, especially newer clients. How often do you see this problem, where the hygienist is really doing some type of scaling, maybe not a heavy-duty, four-quad, quad-an-hour scaling, because that's obviously too big to be ignored, but something that should have been a scaling or gross debridement, and it's charged out as a prophy?
Sabri: I would say I see that 80% of the time.
Jeff: Wow.
Sabri: I see it a lot. And the reason I see it a lot is because of these insurances. Insurance doesn't cover it, so now there's a copay. So who is going to have that conversation? Especially if it's just a limited scaling or a gross debridement. When it's obviously periodontal disease and we're going to do four quads of scaling and root planing, that usually just happens. But it's those other things hygienists are doing that they should be charging for, and I would say 80% of the time they're not. And that boils down to a couple of problems. Why is that occurring? Well, there's no policy.
Jeff: That was going to be my next question, because I know you have a sample with you today, which I'll talk about in a second. Again, since you're interviewing these newer clients, how often do they have some type of policy laying out diagnostic criteria?
Sabri: I don't remember the last time I saw that.
Jeff: For periodontal?
Sabri: For periodontal. And what I'm talking about is something very specific: if this is the condition, this is how we diagnose it, this is how we charge it, this is the treatment for it, and this is how long the appointment is. By just putting a policy in place, it takes it out of the hygienist's hands. It actually makes the conversation easier for the hygienist to have: "I'm very sorry, you fall within this category. I can't do a regular cleaning. I must charge for it."
Jeff: So, not to cut you off, but what you're saying is: I'm the hygienist, and I have a policy. I'm in there doing my thing, and as I get started with the patient, I see, oh my gosh, this looks like it's going to be type X periodontal, whatever. So then I call the doctor over to diagnose it, obviously. But this is based on the doctor's diagnostic criteria in the policy?
Sabri: Correct. The policy comes from the doctor, obviously, and the doctor has to confirm the diagnosis. But there's no reason the hygienist can't talk to the patient about it while they're waiting for the doctor to come in and confirm it. And on top of that, you've role-played with the hygienist on how to have that conversation with patients, so they're comfortable talking to patients about it and answering their questions. And organizationally, you set it up so that if there's an extra charge, it's not up to the hygienist to handle it, because that's not their role in your practice.
Jeff: Well, it's interesting you're saying this, because it's the way any business should really work. You have set policy: if it's this, it's this. If this happens, this happens. This is how we determine we're going to do X. So in this case, you have the doctor create their own. You brought a sample of one, which we have as a free download on the episode webpage, which is awesome, and you can use it to craft your own. Everybody's going to have different criteria.
Sabri: Right. The sample has one of those nasty disclaimers at the beginning, because we're not doctors. But it gives you an idea of the guidelines, of what should be in there. It makes it easier to customize for yourself. You're creating something for yourself with something to use as a basis.
Jeff: So the doctor has written a policy: this is my policy on what constitutes various forms of periodontal therapy. But it's not just a matter of writing it. When you hire a hygienist, you have to, A, go over it with them, and B, make sure they buy into it. Because you don't want a hygienist going, "Well, I don't agree with that."
Sabri: No, of course, because then you're going to have problems.
Jeff: So if the doctor and the hygienist are on the same page with this, and there are very clear-cut diagnostic criteria, then life becomes really easy.
Sabri: It really does. And that's when you start seeing these numbers come up. It's not that anything changes. It's just that you're charging for it now. That's really all. And it's not just good for the practice. It's good for the patient. The patient's home care will improve.
Jeff: Well, yeah, you're right, because now they realize, "Oops, I don't want to do that again." That makes sense. And it's a more accurate representation of what's going on.
Sabri: Exactly.
Jeff: Okay, good. So that's how much they should produce per day and per hour, and why. Now, this is a question we get a lot, but I guess it's really variable: how many patients should they see in a day?
Sabri: On a normal eight-hour day, you would expect them to see at least one patient an hour. Now, as I brought up before, when we were talking about your good point, Jeff...
Jeff: We recorded that for history. Remember that one?
Sabri: Yes. You don't want to get too robotic about it. You do want a bit of policy on how long to schedule each particular patient. And what I've seen in a couple of practices, and this wasn't my idea, I saw other people doing it and thought it was so smart, is this. Usually, when we train a new front desk person, the doctor indicates how much time they need for each patient in dentistry. Well, this particular doctor had their hygienist do the exact same thing: "This is how much time I need for this patient." And very often it was less time. And because they scheduled in 10-minute intervals instead of 15-minute intervals, which is what we recommend, it made that hygienist super productive. The hygienist was using their time correctly. They had enough time to turn over their room and set up for the next patient, but they weren't sitting around because they got an hour for a kid.
Jeff: That makes sense. Okay, good. So that's how many. Obviously, if it's a four-hour day, they'd see maybe four patients. Or three. Okay, never mind, I'll stop. And one an hour is kind of the max. I've seen a lot of offices run 45 minutes per patient.
All right, the next one is assisted hygiene. I know we get asked about this a lot. What are the pros and cons of assisted hygiene? Well, first off, you might want to explain it. Some people still ask what it is, but it's a semi-known concept.
Sabri: Assisted hygiene is when one hygienist handles two columns of patients with an assistant. The assistant seats the patients, turns over the rooms, takes the X-rays, and does everything they're legally allowed to do, and the hygienist just comes in and does what they need to do under their license.
Jeff: I've even seen it, in certain states, and again, don't take this as legal advice, where coronal polishing is legal for an assistant to do, so they'll have the assistant do the coronal polish as well.
Sabri: Exactly. And in states where that's allowed, assisted hygiene may be wonderful. When do people usually do assisted hygiene? Usually for one of two reasons. One, they can't find hygienists. Or two, they have a hygienist they totally love, and they want that hygienist to see every patient. Those are really the pros.
What are the cons? You don't want the hygienist to lose time with the patient, because very often the hygienist is instrumental in presenting dental treatment plans. So if you cut the time the patient spends with the hygienist too short, your sales start suffering. And since we've spoken about this a lot, most of your sales should be coming from hygiene, so you don't want to do anything that interrupts that. You can't schedule your assisted hygiene so tight that your sales suffer.
Jeff: It's interesting. So you're trading off. From a numbers perspective, instead of paying two hygienists, I'm getting almost the production of two hygienists from one hygienist and a dental assistant. But if I lose a ton of dental sales, that's what I'm trading.
Sabri: It's not worth it.
Jeff: So I'm cranking out the cleanings, but I'm not selling the dentistry. And that really doesn't account for perio therapy, where there's nothing the assistant can do.
Sabri: That's exactly right.
Jeff: So the hygienist is going to be in that room for 50 minutes to an hour, cranking anyway.
Sabri: That's exactly right. And the other con is that I'm tying up a second operatory. I could see more patients with two hygienists out of two operatories than with one hygienist and one assistant, because there's always going to be a lag.
Jeff: Got it. I was getting confused too. Two, one, whatever. But it makes sense. It's a more effective use of your time. So the pros are more productivity, and you can see more patients, and the cons are the ones you just gave. So if someone had the choice, two hygienists or assisted hygiene, which would you recommend?
Sabri: The only time I would recommend assisted hygiene is if hygienists were extremely difficult to find in your area. If I could find them, I would always go with two hygienists.
Jeff: Got it. So you would always pick that over assisted hygiene.
Sabri: 100%. Because that patient communication time is so incredibly vital in getting the patient to understand why they need the treatment they need, and to commit to it. Very often, when the doctor comes in for the exam, the only thing they have time for is to sprinkle holy water on something they already diagnosed in the past, with a patient of record. So you want the hygienist to have time to review that treatment plan with the patient. They're part of your clinical staff, and they're great at going over treatment plans.
Jeff: Which brings me to my next question. We get this from clients a couple of different ways: "Should my hygienist help me with treatment presentations?" Or, "How much should they help me?"
Sabri: Absolutely. Ultimately, it's the job of your licensed providers, meaning your hygienists and your doctors...
Jeff: And your assistants, obviously.
Sabri: Yes, but I'm referring specifically to those two. It's their job to advocate for the patient's health. If a patient walks in unhealthy and walks out unhealthy, even if they're healthier, we failed somewhere. Our system failed, unless that patient was just financially destitute, and in most cases that's a rare occurrence. Usually, we didn't make time to sell them. We didn't make time to get them to understand. We weren't effective in getting the patient to understand why they needed it. We didn't have enough financial options. Something went wrong.
When a patient is on the hygiene schedule, the most qualified person, and the person with the most time to have that discussion, is the hygienist. Very often you can get a hygienist on board with discussing the patient's perio needs, but they need to be comfortable going over already diagnosed treatment plans as well.
And I want to make sure I say this right, so nobody gets the wrong idea. I have met very seasoned hygienists who were assistants beforehand, and they're better at spotting things the doctor needs to look at than some newly graduated doctors. And while they cannot diagnose, they can certainly point out issues to the patient: "This is what I'm going to have the doctor talk to you about. I see a crack here. Obviously, we need the doctor to confirm this, but if it's cracked, it's going to need a crown, and this is why." So we need to be careful in the way the hygienist presents this.
Jeff: I see why you said be careful. They can't diagnose.
Sabri: They cannot diagnose.
Jeff: But in my view, there's nothing wrong with a hygienist saying, if a person's missing a tooth, "Hey, have you ever thought of having this tooth replaced?" I mean, the front desk could do that. Or, "Hey, it looks like this crown is loose," or, "There's a big open margin here. I want the doctor to look at this when they're in here."
Sabri: Correct. So the doctor, who usually has limited time for those exams, doesn't have to start from scratch. The hygienist has flagged some things they'd like the doctor to look at that day. They're a healthcare team. They should be working together as a team to get that patient healthy.
Jeff: Which brings up something we've heard before. Someone says, "Yeah, I talked to a hygienist who's happy to clean teeth but doesn't want to help with treatment presentations or treatment acceptance."
Sabri: That's just like a receptionist who won't clean your waiting room: "I'll answer your phone, but I won't clean your waiting room." They do half the job.
Jeff: Or that scheduler we talked about who didn't like making phone calls.
Sabri: Correct. "I'll answer the phone and schedule the patient, but I won't reach out to patients who are unscheduled." It's part of the job. You can't do half the job well. And also, on average, a hygienist is going to spend more time with a patient than the doctor is.
Jeff: And even when the doctor's with a patient doing some type of procedure, they're in and out of the chair very often. Or the procedure they're doing isn't very... what's the word I'm looking for? Conducive to conversation. You've got a rubber dam in the patient's mouth. There's not a lot of conversation coming back.
Sabri: Right. With a hygienist, it's not like that.
Jeff: No, not at all. So should the hygienist be part of that sales discussion, that treatment presentation?
Sabri: Absolutely.
Jeff: Treatment presentation is a pretty word for sales.
Sabri: I know, right? So yes, I want them to be part of it. Personally, if I were a dentist hiring a hygienist who wouldn't do that, I wouldn't hire them, just like I wouldn't hire an associate doctor who wouldn't have a discussion with the patient about their needs. I just wouldn't do it.
Jeff: That would be a non-starter for you?
Sabri: Yes, because they need to work together as a team. They only have limited time, so the person with the time available needs to do it.
Jeff: Okay. And let's say we have somebody listening, a doctor, or a doctor and a hygienist, who want to get better at this. Would you suggest they role-play a bit, how it would work with a patient?
Sabri: Role-playing is always a great thing, especially coming up with the objections they run into, like, how would I handle those objections? And obviously, I'm always going to recommend the MGE sales seminars. That is what we teach. The reason we have a thriving business is that nobody teaches doctors how to sell.
Jeff: Well, it's also called the Communication and Sales Seminars, because really, with hygiene, you're not asking the hygienist to diagnose and present a treatment plan. But they're supposed to be effectively communicating and helping people notice things.
Sabri: That's exactly right. And I've seen a lot of cases where the doctor walks in and looks at something, and the hygienist has built up enough of a rapport with the patient that the patient turns to the hygienist and goes, "What do you think?" And the hygienist says, "He's really good. You should really do what he says."
Jeff: That makes sense. I'll put a link to the Communication and Sales Seminars on the episode webpage. All right, well, I think those were the big questions, and I think we may be coming up on our 30-minute mark.
Sabri: Oh, just close. You know what it is? Just like associates and dentists aren't taught the business side of dentistry, which means that if they don't know it, they can't do dentistry, because you need to get patients in the chair and get them to pay for their services in order to build a practice, neither are hygienists. And very often, from what I've seen when I've spoken to hygienists, they're being told directly, "You should never have a financial conversation with a patient," or "You should not be going over dentistry." So sometimes it's just a matter of reteaching your hygienist and figuring out a way for them to do it that they're comfortable with.
Jeff: I mean, I guess the finances wouldn't be that critical, but definitely the treatment aspect would be critical, right?
Sabri: Yes. But patients are going to ask, "How much is an implant?" "A few thousand dollars." They don't need to work out how to pay for it, but they need to be able to say how much something costs.
Jeff: No, I agree. They're part of the sales team. And if somebody has a problem with that, that's probably not an ideal fit.
Sabri: Exactly.
Jeff: All right, well, Sabri, I think that hits all the questions I had for you. Thank you so much for joining us this week.
Sabri: You are so welcome.
Jeff: Super, super appreciated. Now, if people have any questions about this, do you mind if they email you?
Sabri: Of course.
Jeff: I'll put your email address on the episode webpage.
Sabri: Of course. It's sabrib@mgeonline.com.
Jeff: We'll put a link to it on the episode webpage, so you can always email Sabri. We also have the downloads we just mentioned. I have the free form from Sabri, which is the clinical guidelines for setting up your own perio policy in your practice. We also have the links to the MGE Communication and Sales Seminars. Folks, if you want to know more about MGE, you can always find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. I do hope this helps. Have a great week, and we'll see you at the next episode.