You can present the perfect treatment plan and still lose the case during the handoff. Jeff and Sabri explain how doctors and treatment coordinators can work together to create a smoother transition and increase treatment acceptance.
Morning Production Meeting - https://www.mgeonline.com/morning-production-meeting-download/
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
Why does Sabri say the doctor's presentation and the treatment coordinator's follow-up need to function as "one conversation"?
If the handoff feels like two separate, disconnected conversations, the patient loses the relationship and context they built with the doctor the moment they're passed along. Treating it as a single continuous conversation, ideally with the treatment coordinator present for the whole presentation, keeps the patient's trust intact through the entire process.
What must the doctor confirm before a patient is ever handed off to the treatment coordinator?
The patient needs to genuinely understand their condition in plain language, the consequences of not treating it, and the doctor's specific recommended treatment, not a menu of options to choose from themselves. The doctor also needs to directly ask whether the patient wants to move forward with treatment, separate from whether they've agreed to pay for it, before any handoff happens.
When does Sabri say it's acceptable for the treatment coordinator not to be in the room during the doctor's presentation?
Only with a genuinely, extremely experienced treatment coordinator the doctor has already worked closely with. Even then, for larger cases, she still recommends having the treatment coordinator present, and for anything close to a $40,000 case, she says the two should have already reviewed it together beforehand so they're fully aligned before even walking into the room.
What does Sabri identify as the single most common point where the handoff actually breaks down?
The transition itself, when a doctor creates a treatment plan and simply has an assistant send it to the treatment coordinator with no real communication. The treatment coordinator ends up meeting the patient and discussing a large sum of money with zero relationship or context, which Sabri says feels cold and avoidable for everyone involved.
What's an example Jeff and Sabri give of a small gesture that makes a real difference in how a patient experiences the practice?
Jeff describes watching a receptionist personally walk over and sit with a delayed patient in the waiting room rather than just calling out an update from behind the desk, which visibly put the patient at ease. They both point to this kind of personalized attention, along with properly introducing the treatment coordinator to the patient, as simple steps that meaningfully shape how comfortable a patient feels.
Episode Transcript
-
Jeff: So you see a new patient, and you've diagnosed a considerably large treatment plan. You've explained it to them, and they seem to become more and more engaged as you're going through it, motivated and excited to get started. They want to do this, and they've told you as much. So you pass them off to your treatment coordinator and head off to your next patient, expecting to see them on your schedule in the next two or three days, since that's what you two were just discussing.
A little later in the day, you get a chance to peek at your schedule. You look at the next two or three days, no patient. You check next week, still nothing. You look further out, nothing there either. So when you get a minute, you go talk to your treatment coordinator to find out what happened, since this patient seemed genuinely motivated when you left them.
You find out some objection came up that the treatment coordinator just couldn't handle, they needed to think about it, talk to their spouse, it wasn't a good time, it was too expensive, the usual stuff. You might ask a few follow-up questions, did you say this, did you ask that, and they report that they did everything they were supposed to. It's just plain frustrating. So what went wrong?
Any number of things could have gone wrong, but in a lot of these cases, the failure actually comes down to the handoff itself, that pass to the treatment coordinator was somehow broken. And here's the thing about treatment acceptance: a properly done handoff, done consistently, can dramatically increase overall office collections and treatment acceptance. When it's broken or not functioning correctly, you end up with less acceptance, or, like in this example, none at all.
So for this week's episode, we want to examine this handoff process thoroughly, how it should work, who should be doing what, where it tends to break, and how to fix it, with actionable steps you can put to use right away to start increasing treatment acceptance and getting more patients the treatment they actually need. My name is Jeff Blumberg, and I'm your host, joined today by Sabri Blumberg, who many of you know if you've been listening for any length of time. If you haven't heard her before, she's our Deputy Chief Operating Officer here at MGE, and she's also in charge of all of MGE's technical delivery. She's also the author of an upcoming book, When Insurance Companies Took Over Dentistry, which you'll be seeing before too long, covering insurance generally and how to actually get out of network. And as you could probably guess from our last names, we're married, which is why we tend to talk a lot.
Sabri, welcome to the show.
Sabri: Hello, Jeff.
Jeff: This is a fairly simple subject, but I know you've got plenty to say about it. Let's start with the handoff itself. How should it work, and who should be doing what?
Sabri: The first thing I want to establish is the core concept behind the handoff: there are certain things the doctor must do, certain things the treatment coordinator should do, and a best way to handle each piece, but the very first thing people need to understand is that this is one conversation.
Jeff: That's an interesting way to frame it, the treatment coordinator is continuing the conversation, not starting a new one.
Sabri: Exactly. There are roles the doctor must play and roles the treatment coordinator plays, and how that balance works shifts depending on how experienced the treatment coordinator is. But there are things the doctor must always do before the handoff happens. By the time the treatment coordinator actually gets the patient, the doctor needs to have explained the patient's condition clearly, "here's what's going on," in plain language, no dental jargon.
Jeff: Nothing like "periapical radiolucency."
Sabri: Exactly, patients don't have a dental degree, they don't know what that means. Even the word "abscess" isn't something a lot of people actually understand. I find a lot of people don't even fully register "infection" the way we mean it, to them, infection means a fever. Something plain works much better: "there's bacteria, little organisms sitting on your teeth, that's why they feel a bit slimy, and what they're excreting is eroding your enamel." You have to explain it in language people genuinely understand, while still keeping it professional.
So the patient needs a real understanding of their condition, the consequences of not addressing it, and the actual treatment being recommended. There might be multiple treatment options, a crown, an inlay, a bridge, an implant, but you can't hand the patient a menu and let them choose. Give them the options, but the doctor needs to recommend what they genuinely believe is the best path forward, and commit to that recommendation. "You could technically get a partial, but the smartest thing here is placing these implants, so that's what we're going to do."
The patient needs a crystal-clear picture of the condition, the consequences, and the treatment, and they need to have actually understood it, not just nodded along. You can tell when someone doesn't really understand what you're saying, that glazed-over look. So talk to your patient, not at them. Ask if they got that, whether they have questions, "you look like you might have a question, what are you thinking?"
Once the doctor has done all of that and given at least a ballpark cost, they need to ask directly, "do you want to do this treatment?" The patient doesn't get handed off to the treatment coordinator until they've agreed to the treatment itself. That doesn't mean they've agreed to pay for it yet.
Jeff: Sometimes the patient will say exactly that, "I don't know, that's expensive, I don't know how I'd pay for it."
Sabri: Right, and you'd say, "I didn't ask how you'd pay for it yet, I know that's a separate conversation, but do you want to do the treatment?" Once they say yes, now you're ready for the financial conversation, and that's when you hand off to the treatment coordinator.
Jeff: Would the treatment coordinator ideally have been in the room the whole time?
Sabri: Ideally, yes. They've heard everything you've said, heard how you handled whatever objections came up, and can stay consistent with that. They also already know those specific objections have been addressed, so if the patient brings one up again with them, that's a signal there's probably a different, unvoiced objection underneath it.
Jeff: So walking through this as the doctor: I sit with the patient, treatment coordinator's in the room, I go over what's wrong, what I want to do about it, the consequences of not treating it, I make sure I've explained it simply and confirmed they actually understood, and at the end I've asked if they want to move forward and given a ballpark figure. And ideally the treatment coordinator's been there for all of it.
Sabri: Exactly. Then the handoff itself happens. At minimum, if the treatment coordinator wasn't in the room, the doctor needs to bring them in and go over everything in front of the patient. I'd say something like, "Hi Susie," introducing the treatment coordinator, "this is patient so-and-so, this is their condition, we've already discussed all of this, they understand the cost, and they want to move forward with treatment. Is that all correct?" The patient confirms, "yes, yes, yes." "Good, any other questions for me?" That's the absolute minimum viable handoff.
Jeff: But ideally the doctor could go further, "your portion's going to be $10,000," assuming I've already confirmed they want it, and they say "wow, that's a lot," and I can ask, "how would you normally pay for something like this," "probably a credit card," "do you have it with you," "yeah, my Visa," "great," or "actually I might want to look into financing instead," "sure, I'll have you talk that through with Susie," and that's the turnover.
Sabri: Exactly right.
Jeff: One thing that comes up a lot, I'm sure you get asked this too: the default is always to have the treatment coordinator in the room. When would it actually be okay not to?
Sabri: Only with a genuinely, extremely experienced treatment coordinator. That's the one exception. And honestly, if your practice is busy enough that this keeps happening, it should've been worked out ahead of time in a morning meeting.
Jeff: Or the treatment coordinator's just still wrapping up with another patient who happens to be a real talker.
Sabri: Right, in that case, with a genuinely experienced treatment coordinator the doctor is already used to working with, you'd have the patient wait briefly rather than rush the handoff. Tell them, "have a seat, it'll be about ten minutes, then I'll bring in the treatment coordinator." Or if there's an office manager who can step in, even better, you'd never make the patient wait in that case. But if waiting is genuinely unavoidable, the doctor still needs to personally come back and do the actual turnover, even though that's an annoying interruption.
Jeff: So the less experienced the treatment coordinator, the more essential it is to have them in the room during the presentation.
Sabri: A hundred percent.
Jeff: Would you apply that same logic to larger treatment plans specifically?
Sabri: Yes, absolutely, until the treatment coordinator reaches a level of experience where they can genuinely close something that size on their own. But for something like a $40,000 case, you want the treatment coordinator in the room every time, you want to do everything right on a case that large.
Jeff: What does "everything right" actually look like for a case like that?
Sabri: It means the doctor and treatment coordinator have already gone over the case privately, ideally in the morning meeting or even before it. The doctor's reviewed the x-rays, even for an existing patient, to refamiliarize themselves, "I'm presenting this case today," and the treatment coordinator understands exactly what's coming and is already in sync before they even walk into the room together.
Jeff: So if I'm presenting five cases tomorrow, I'd meet with my treatment coordinator that morning, or even the day before, and go through each one, "we're seeing Mrs. Jones, here's what's going on with her, we're seeing Bob Smith, here's his situation," and the treatment coordinator can ask questions ahead of time, how we're planning to sequence it, how we're scheduling it, so we're both completely in the groove before we actually walk in.
Sabri: Exactly, remember, it's one conversation. You want to be fully aligned before you ever see that patient together. You obviously can't do this ahead of time with a brand-new patient, but it's perfectly fine to have that new patient wait a few minutes while the doctor and treatment coordinator quickly sync up beforehand, "here's what I'm running into with this patient," so the treatment coordinator has no open questions by the time they actually see the patient together.
Jeff: I don't think it's a bad idea even same-day, if we've diagnosed a patient today and have time to present it today, before I go in, I'd step out and brief the treatment coordinator on what we're about to present, especially if they're going to be in the room with me.
Sabri: Exactly, "here's what's going on with this patient, here's what I'm going to cover," and they're already thinking along with you. The more you can make it feel like one continuous conversation instead of two disconnected ones, the smoother the handoff goes, and the smoother things go between you and the treatment coordinator too.
Jeff: So say I've done my part, I've handed the patient off, and then something goes wrong. Should I be looped back in, or should the treatment coordinator just handle it and let me know afterward?
Sabri: It depends. There are specific situations where the doctor should be brought back in. If it's a large treatment plan, genuinely health-related rather than cosmetic, and the patient suddenly does a complete reversal with the treatment coordinator, at that point I'd tell the patient, "the doctor's concerned about this, let me bring them back so they can at least go over how to manage the condition in the meantime, until you're ready to move forward."
Jeff: So something's gone sideways, and I'm getting pulled back into the room.
Sabri: Right, so the doctor can address it directly, "that tooth's cracked, so try to chew on the other side for now, otherwise you risk putting extra strain there too and creating a second problem," whatever the clinically appropriate explanation is, to see if the patient can be brought back on board.
Jeff: What if the patient changes the treatment plan itself, say it's six crowns and they say they only want to do two this year and the rest spread out to maximize insurance?
Sabri: Then someone has to decide which two crowns get done, and that's not a decision the treatment coordinator can make, nobody but the doctor can make that call. So you'd need to bring the doctor back in for that.
Jeff: But if it's more like, "yes, I'm doing this, I'll do financing, you can start the paperwork," or "I can fill everything out but can't actually run it until I talk to my husband tonight," that doesn't require pulling the doctor back in.
Sabri: Right, that's genuinely circumstantial. Once the doctor's done their part, the treatment coordinator takes over to finalize financial arrangements and get the patient scheduled.
Jeff: So where do you actually see this handoff break down most often?
Sabri: If the doctor skips any of those earlier pieces, the patient doesn't really understand the treatment, the consequences, or the condition itself, or is confused between multiple options with no clear recommendation from the doctor, any of that can already break the process before it even reaches the treatment coordinator. But the single biggest breaking point is the actual transition from doctor to treatment coordinator. The doctor makes a treatment plan, has an assistant send it over to the treatment coordinator, and there's simply no real communication, no genuine turnover. It's the first time the treatment coordinator is seeing this patient or this plan at all.
Jeff: So it's basically, "hi, I'm Jeff, give me $10,000."
Sabri: Essentially, yes, and it's just not smooth. The treatment coordinator was never part of that original conversation, and the patient has no relationship with them either. The patient's relationship was with the doctor, and that relationship was never actually transferred.
Jeff: So in a way, the doctor is bringing the treatment coordinator into the patient's circle of trust.
Sabri: Exactly, so the patient feels comfortable talking to them too. Ideally, for a new patient, the treatment coordinator meets them early, introduces themselves, "I'll be taking care of you today, you'll see the doctor first, and if anything's needed, you'll come talk to me afterward, and I'm going to make sure you have a good visit."
Jeff: There's not always time for that, though.
Sabri: Not always, it depends on the treatment coordinator's workload and new patient volume that day, but when there is time, build that relationship right from the start. You could even have the treatment coordinator be part of the intake process itself, so there's already a real relationship there instead of, "I need $15,000 worth of treatment from you, and who are you again?"
Jeff: That is a bit cold, dropping someone in front of a patient with zero context.
Sabri: It really is, and it's rough on both the patient and the treatment coordinator, and it's entirely avoidable.
Jeff: So beyond the doctor's own sales process, what would you actually tell people to do to fix this?
Sabri: Coordinate better. Ideally before the morning meeting, the doctor and treatment coordinator should sit down for a few minutes and review existing patients with pending treatment, along with any new patients coming in and whatever known information is already on their intake forms, a recall patient who's 22 and probably not presenting much, versus a new patient who already mentioned sensitivity and wants to discuss veneers. That way both of you walk into the actual morning meeting already aligned on how the day's sales opportunities should play out. This assumes you're running a real morning production meeting, which you should be, we have a write-up on this, I'll put a link on the episode webpage.
Jeff: So the night before, or right before the meeting, as the treatment coordinator I'm looking at tomorrow's schedule, patients of record the doctor's already diagnosed, since those are my sales opportunities, whether they're on recall or the doctor's schedule, plus any new patients with known data.
Sabri: Right, and the doctor and treatment coordinator sit down together and go through it, "what about this one, what about that one," building a real plan, confirming it that morning, making sure everyone's actually confirmed to show up, so you're never walking into these presentations cold. When the doctor is presenting treatment to a patient, they're wearing part of the sales role at that moment, they're part of the sales team, not just functioning purely as a clinician. So you want that sales team genuinely coordinated, which is exactly why it's worth spending a little time making sure the doctor understands their part of the handoff. Have the treatment coordinator in the room whenever the schedule allows, have some agreement on how far the doctor is going to personally take the sale, are they asking about payment method themselves, or leaving that entirely to the treatment coordinator, and with new patients, let the treatment coordinator introduce themselves and start building that relationship before the patient even goes back for their exam, if that's workable.
Jeff: It's funny, these are small things most people wouldn't necessarily think to prioritize, but they make a real difference.
Sabri: They really do. Even something like a patient sitting in reception because the doctor's running fifteen minutes behind, most people handle that fine, but walking out personally and saying, "I just wanted to let you know the doctor's running a bit behind with their last patient, they've assured me you'll be seated by 2:15, is there anything I can get you in the meantime," something that small makes a genuine difference, the same way personally turning the patient over to the treatment coordinator in front of them does. It makes the patient comfortable, and that's really what you're after.
Jeff: That reminds me, I was in an office a few years back, and instead of just talking to a delayed patient over the counter, I watched the receptionist actually turn the phones over, walk away from the desk, and go sit in the waiting room next to the patient to talk with them directly.
Sabri: That's such a nice thing to do.
Jeff: You could see the patient smiling, and you could tell they genuinely registered, "this actually matters to them."
Sabri: That kind of personalized attention makes a huge difference, it really does.
Jeff: Anything else you'd add? I knew this wasn't going to turn into a three-hour episode, but it's important enough to deserve its own focus.
Sabri: I think the biggest thing is just talk to patients, not at them. That means an actual conversation, and a lot of patients won't naturally volunteer much, so you have to draw them out, "what are you thinking, any concerns about this?" Pause while you're talking to actually engage them, speak with them, not just deliver information at them.
Jeff: That's a great note to end on. Sabri, thank you so much for being on.
Sabri: Of course.
Jeff: Folks, that's all I have for you this week. I've got that download for the morning production meeting on the episode webpage if you'd like to check it out. If you want to find out more about MGE, you can find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. Have a great week, and we'll see you at the next episode.