Your staffing problems might have less to do with who you're hiring and more to do with how you're training them. In this week's episode, Jeff and Sabri reveal the common mistakes that lead to poor performance, frustration, and unnecessary turnover.
EP 267 Handouts - https://www.mgeonline.com/ep-267-podcast-downloads-form-page/
Have a question for Jeff?
Fill out the form and he will get back to you.
Questions From This Episode
What should you define before you hire a dental team member?
What the job produces. Sabri says many owners can't say what a position's deliverable is, so staff can't deliver it. Before hiring, put in writing each function of the job and the minimum realistic quantity the practice needs, such as daily production, show rate, or reactivations scheduled, and include it in the offer letter. That gives you an agreement to come back to when you train or correct. As she puts it, front desk is a piece of furniture, not a position.
How do you keep a new hire from not showing up on day one?
When they accept the offer, ask for their word that they will start on the agreed date, and ask them to give you at least a week's notice if anything changes, since you are stopping your search. Sabri also suggests asking whether they have other interviews and telling them not to be afraid to let you know. It won't prevent every no-show, but most people will at least give you a heads-up.
What should a new dental employee's first day look like?
An orientation. Give them a written checklist and a buddy who knows the office, and have them find the operatories, the hygiene rooms, the supplies, and the bathrooms, and meet the team. If they have no dental experience, teach basic dental terms. Sabri also recommends having new front desk staff spend a day in the back turning over rooms, so they understand the procedures they will be scheduling.
In what order should you train a new dental employee?
From easiest to hardest, one function at a time. Start with low-risk tasks that can't cost you much if the person doesn't work out: reactivation calls at the front, sterilization in the back, or regular recall patients for a new hygienist. Have someone check their work, and once they can do it well, add the next function. Even if it takes a week or two, you end up with someone trained to do the whole job.
How quickly can you tell if a new hire won't work out?
Often within two or three days. Sabri uses reactivation calls and sterilization as her litmus tests. A slow first day can be corrected, but if results don't improve dramatically by day two or three, the person probably won't make it. She says the biggest hiring mistake is not firing: owners hold on too long, often ignoring doubts they had during the interview.
Episode Transcript
-
Jeff: Four out of 10. In any given month, four out of 10 dental practices in the United States are trying to hire an assistant or a hygienist. That's from the ADA's own Health Policy Institute. And if it's a hygienist you're after, it's probably been a little tough: 90% of the dentists recruiting hygienists say it's very or extremely hard. Only about two in five actually filled the spot. And admin staff is definitely hit or miss, especially compared to how things were back in 2019.
So you finally find somebody, you bring them on, and here's what you're up against: 44% of new hires regret taking the job within the first week. The first week. And you've got about 44 days to change their mind. About 40% of all turnover happens in the first year, and for roughly three out of four of the people who leave, their exit was preventable. Nearly one in five dental assistants, for example, changed jobs just in the past year. And every time one of them walks out the door, it costs you, whether it's a front desk person, an assistant, or a hygienist.
Replacing one employee can run anywhere from half to twice their annual salary, and Gallup calls that a conservative estimate. And here's the kicker. Only about 12% of employees strongly agree that their employer does a great job of onboarding new people. 12%.
And look, people leave dental practices for a lot of reasons: pay, feeling underappreciated, maybe they're doing a bad job, et cetera. But bad training is how an office keeps bleeding money and people over and over and never figures out why. Good training can also detect problem employees before you're too far into the mix.
And this is what we see all the time. Offices don't train incrementally. They hire somebody, hand them a whole manual, tell them to read the thing in the break room, and then say, "Okay, you're good. Go do the job." That's not training. That's hoping. Nobody is thinking about how to properly train somebody. So that's what we're going to talk about in this week's episode. How do you train your staff correctly? What's the basic sequence? What comes first? What comes next? And how do you end up with a good staff instead of starting over every six months?
My name is Jeff Blumberg, and I'm your host. And joining me today is Sabri Blumberg, who many of you will know if you've been listening to the podcast for any length of time. She's the Deputy Chief Operating Officer here at MGE. She's in charge of all of MGE's technical delivery and works with many of our clients. She's also the author of an upcoming book, When Insurance Companies Took Over Dentistry, which you'll be seeing soon. And as you can tell, she and I have the same last name. We're married, and have been for quite some time, so we tend to, or at least we hope to, talk. Right?
Sabri: Yeah.
Jeff: Sabri's there. There we go. She's been listening the whole time. All right, Sabri, welcome to the show.
Sabri: Thanks, Jeff.
Jeff: All right. I'm just going to let you roll with this, because Sabri's worked with thousands of our clients. She's been doing what she does since the late '90s, since the Clinton administration, right? So you work with a lot of clients.
Sabri: I do.
Jeff: You see all the errors that get made. People are doing it wrong. And that was how you came at me for this episode. You're like, "Look, people are training staff wrong." So I don't know how you want to start with this. Do you want to go over what they're doing wrong, or do you want to go into how you should train somebody? I'll leave that up to you.
Sabri: I think a little bit of both. The first thing I want to discuss is that it really starts when you're hiring the person. Very often, I run into a problem where a client's having trouble with staff, and I ask them, "Well, what is this person supposed to do? What is this person supposed to produce for you? What is the deliverable on their job?" And the owner doesn't know. "Well, they're the front desk. They answer the phone, and they verify some insurances, and they help with confirmations, and they do this, and they do that." So the owner is confused on what the deliverable is.
Jeff: Okay.
Sabri: So what do you think is happening to the staff? Or they're saying, "Well, the staff's just not doing the job." And I'm like, "Well, what is the job? What are they supposed to make?" When you're giving anybody money, you're buying something, right? It's a contract between two people, between an owner and an employee, and the agreement is, "I am going to give you this much money, and in return, you are going to give me this."
Jeff: This is what they're supposed to deliver in exchange.
Sabri: Exactly. And if you can't define the "this," which is what happens, I'm like, "Well, what's the this? Do you go over that in the hiring process? Do you tell them?" Because I see this get kind of crazy. I see somebody hiring a front desk, and they say, "Okay, well, this person's going to do your confirmations. I need them working on the outstanding treatment list and scheduling consults and this, that, and the other thing."
Jeff: This is what you're telling them. This is what you need the person doing.
Sabri: Yeah. Well, this person doesn't like making phone calls. And I'm like, "Well, didn't they know that this was the job when you hired them?" Well, no. So I think a lot of problems start right at hiring. There's not a clear understanding of exactly what you are expecting this person to produce, and in what quantity. And the staff member has to understand this. You're not paying for their time. You're not paying for their sunny personality. You're paying for this much production on the schedule, this many people in hygiene every day, this level of show rate. That's what you're buying. So I think it starts with everybody having a clear idea of exactly what you want the person you're hiring for that function to produce.
Jeff: Now, it's interesting you say that, only because if I hire a janitor, just by virtue of their title, they know I'm expecting them to perform janitorial services. I may have to give them the fine points: clean this, don't touch that, dust this, wax this floor once a week, et cetera.
Sabri: Correct.
Jeff: But they at least have an idea: "Okay, I'm the janitor. I'm supposed to do this." Same thing with a hygienist, or even a dental assistant to some degree.
Sabri: Sure. It's much easier with those functions, because it's much clearer what you want them to do. But even with a hygienist: a hygienist is an integral part of your sales team, especially when you're expecting a lot of your future production to come out of hygiene on those incomplete treatment plans. If your hygienist is unwilling to talk to their patients about already diagnosed treatment, educate them on it, and be part of your sales team so you can get these patients healthy, and that wasn't clearly mentioned when you hired that person, you're going to run into problems.
So even with assistants and hygienists, you need to be very clear: "This is exactly what I'm buying for the amount of money. This is how many operatories we work out of. This is how many patients we see. This is exactly what I expect you to do, and the manner and speed I expect you to do it in. And in exchange, I will give you this much money. Can you do that?" And if they say yes, now at least you have an agreement you can come back to.
Jeff: Like an expectation.
Sabri: Right, when you're correcting them or when you're training them, because there was an agreement.
Jeff: I'm sort of watching you and listening to you at the same time. How often, because I used to hear this a lot, do doctors tell you, "Well, my hygienist doesn't want to help with the treatment presentation or acceptance process"?
Sabri: Much more than I would like to hear it.
Jeff: If you had to estimate a percentage? I know this isn't science.
Sabri: Probably three out of 10.
Jeff: Really? Okay. So it's still a thing.
Sabri: It's always been a thing.
Jeff: No, I remember it being a thing. I just didn't know if it was still a thing.
Sabri: It's still a thing. When you're hiring people, you have a concept of all the functions that position is supposed to produce for the organization.
Jeff: Or you should, they don't always have a concept.
Sabri: Correct. You should have a clear concept before you hire that person. And if you want to do this correctly, when you hire the person, you usually give them an offer letter. That should be in your offer letter. That is the agreement you're making that you can come back to. Especially when we're dealing with administrative people, it can really come down to, "I'm hiring a front desk. I'm hiring you to be a front desk person." Front desk is a piece of furniture. It's not a position. It doesn't produce anything.
Jeff: You need a division of labor where people have assigned functions.
Sabri: Exactly. But the functions change from office to office, depending on the size of the office, the type of dentistry they're doing, and just their own philosophy. So what a receptionist does in one office is not necessarily what a receptionist does in another one. Are you going to expect them to ask for reviews? If so, how many do you expect a week? Are you going to expect them to work on referrals? Are you going to expect them to clean the public bathroom? Because I hear that too: "Why don't they take out the trash?" "My receptionist won't clean." Yeah, but did you go over that with them when you hired them? They have the right to decline the job, like, "I won't do that." But don't hire somebody, expect them to do something, add it later, and then find out afterward that they're unwilling to do it.
Jeff: So if I have staff and they're not doing certain things I'd like them to do, I can always ask them to, assuming it falls along the lines of their job. But the lesson from this is, before I go to hire, I should clearly outline what I want this person to do.
Sabri: Correct, and it should be in writing: the functions of the job, and the minimum expected quantity for the viability of the practice. It should be clearly noted, and not just scheduled production. How much production do you need them to deliver every day that's realistic? Don't go with some pie-in-the-sky goal. Where are we starting here? What is the absolute irreducible minimum they need to meet for you to be able to afford to keep them?
Jeff: Interesting. Okay, so that's the first place.
Sabri: That's the first place, and I know it's got nothing to do with training, but when you start training them...
Jeff: I think it's smart, because then you're not training somebody who's going to say later on, "Well, I never wanted to do this."
Sabri: Correct. Then the next thing: once you have that understanding of everything they'll be doing in the job, the quantity they should be doing it in, and what you're expecting. For example, if they're taking new patient phone calls, what do you expect the conversion rate to be? If they're going to make reactivation calls, how many people do you expect them to schedule every day? Those agreements have to be in place. Now you can look at training them.
Ordinarily, when we're training, especially administrative people, what I see is we hand the new employee a notepad and a pen and say, "Okay, now I'm going to tell you everything, and I'm going to show you how the software works, and I'm going to show you this and where we keep this." And in a state of desperation, that poor staff member is trying to keep up and note everything. That's not training at all. There's no way somebody can learn like that, even if they have experience, because there are always peculiarities to a job. Every office is different. We all do it differently. And if you don't train them properly, especially when they have, quote-unquote, "experience," they're going to do it the way they did it in their last job, because that's what they know. That might be really different from the way you do it and mess up your whole system. So even experienced people, you need to train.
Jeff: So let me ask, then. Let's say you go, "Jeff, I'm going to hire you to do this," and you've given me what's expected of me. "You're going to be scheduling. We expect this much production per day, and we expect to add a day of hygiene a week every year. We expect this, we expect this," whatever the expectations are. And I go, "Cool, that sounds great," and I accept the offer. So what do you do with me next?
Sabri: The first thing I would tell them when they accept the offer is, "I expect you to show up." I don't expect the day to start and you just not show up. I see that a shocking amount lately.
Jeff: Yeah, there seems to be more of that. I've heard more of it. People take jobs and they just don't show up.
Sabri: So I would let them know, "I cannot have you agree to start a job and not start it, so you and I are going to make an agreement here, and you're going to give me your word. You're going to take this job, and we're starting on this date. If for whatever reason anything changes, you're going to give me at least a week's notice, because I'm going to stop hiring now. You understand that, right?"
Jeff: Now, can I stop you there for a sec? Not to stop you, but I have questions now. I had a lot more one-on-one client meetings a few years back. I talk to all our clients now, but not sit-down, two-hour meetings, the nitty-gritty of it all. And I hear this in seminars: "I hired this person, and they no-showed." It seems to be happening a lot more since 2020. And why? I don't know. I'm not going to speculate.
Sabri: Well, we could. I've speculated.
Jeff: Being older, my mind goes to the young generation. Get off my lawn.
Sabri: It just makes me feel old.
Jeff: Yeah, exactly. It makes me feel old, so I'm not going to do that. Maybe work culture changed, with a lot of people working from home. I don't know. Doesn't matter. So how often is that happening? That's the first question. And the follow-up is, have you ever had anybody do this, say, "Listen, you're going to give me your word you're starting," and what effect did that have?
Sabri: I can't tell you accurately how often it's happening, because I didn't actually run any metrics on it, so I'd just be pulling a number out of the air.
Jeff: It used to be once in a blue moon. Now it's a regular thing.
Sabri: It was something I'd never heard of until recently, and now it seems to be like, "Oh yeah, we hired somebody. We'll see if they show up." I'm like, what is this?
Jeff: It used to be they didn't show for interviews.
Sabri: Well, people have always done that. That I understand. That's why we started doing the group interviews, because we were sick of allocating time for people who don't show up.
Jeff: As an aside, group interviews are great, especially for administrative staff. I wouldn't use them for hygienists or assistants unless you have a bazillion applicants for assistant. But if you're interested in the group interview method, I'll put a copy of our handout on group interviews on the episode webpage for download.
Sabri: Oh, I think that's great.
Jeff: Thought I'd throw that in there.
Sabri: So how often do they not show up? I can't say. Maybe a third of the time, but I hear it an awful lot. Now, the guys who are being real with their staff,
Jeff: Telling them, "You're agreeing to this with me." Because I think what some people are doing is going, "Okay, good, I accept the job," and maybe they have three other jobs they're stringing along. Then they find greener pastures, "Oh, the grass is greener, I'm going over there," and they just don't say anything.
Sabri: Correct.
Jeff: So does it prevent this from happening, telling somebody, "Listen, if you're not going to show up, I at least expect a little bit of professionalism from you to let me know"?
Sabri: Does it prevent it from happening? No. But most people have the courtesy, or at least the guilt, to say something.
Jeff: So the guys who are being real, what are they finding when they do this?
Sabri: They at least get a heads-up, like, "Hey, I found another position. I'm going to take that one." And you can say, "Listen, are you still interviewing? Do you have other interviews after this one?" "Yeah, I have two more." "So it could happen that you like another job more than the one I offered?" "Yeah, that could happen." "Good. Well, do me a favor. Don't be scared to let me know, because right now I expect you to start on this date, and I'm not looking for anybody else. So if you're not going to take it, let me know as soon as possible." It's almost like these people don't have a good, clear idea of the consequences of their actions. They just can't see that far. Now, personally, I think if somebody did that to you, you dodged a bullet.
Jeff: Oh, heck yeah. If somebody at least gives me a heads-up, it's like, "Thank you."
Sabri: Right. At least you dodged a bullet, and I feel bad for the person they're working for now. So I wouldn't feel bad about your loss. It's just time you could have spent continuing to look.
Jeff: Okay, I like that. So if they're going to go off somewhere else, fine. Now let's assume they've shown up. Okay, so we're at the good stuff now. You gave me my offer. It had all the stuff in it that I was going to be doing, so there are no misunderstandings later. Obviously we're not signing a contract, but at least we're laying out what the expectations are.
Sabri: It's an offer letter.
Jeff: Right. Exactly. You gave me my offer, and I showed up. So what happens now?
Sabri: The first thing you do is an orientation with the staff member, and the best way to do that is to put it in writing. You give them a little checklist to follow, and you assign them a little buddy, somebody who knows the office. "Go find out where the bathrooms are. Go locate op one. Go locate op two. Go locate op three. Okay, which ones are the hygiene ops? Go find the paper supply." You just orient them to the basics of the office. We do have a sample orientation sheet. I don't know if you want to put that up or not.
Jeff: Yeah, I'll put that up as a free download.
Sabri: Okay, good. When somebody starts a new job, regardless of whether they have experience or not, they don't know your office, and people always feel a little bit disoriented, because it's really not their office yet. Remember the first day you started high school? You felt weird and out of place, you weren't comfortable, and you were fumbling around trying to figure out, "Where do I put my lunch, and where's the coffee?"
Jeff: Where's this class?
Sabri: And where's this?
Jeff: I ate lunch at school.
Sabri: Right. Okay. Whatever. You get the idea.
Jeff: Yeah, I know. But yeah, where's room 102?
Sabri: Right. So the first thing you do is an orientation, where they meet the staff, they know where everything is, and they feel comfortable in the space. From there, you go back to your offer letter, look at all the functions you wanted them to be able to do, and sequence those from easiest to most difficult. The easiest thing might be to make a reactivation phone call. That is extraordinarily easy. Or to sterilize instruments.
Jeff: Sure, if they're in the back.
Sabri: Right, or whatever it may be. So you break the functions down into edible pieces. You don't teach them all at once. You get them good at one thing, and then you add to it.
Jeff: All right. So let's say at the front, teaching somebody to do a reactivation call is pretty quick. So I've taught them to do a reactivation call. I show them how to identify who to call, and then I put them on the phone.
Sabri: Yes. Now you have them do it. Don't start with answering the phone. You want to start them on something where, if the staff member isn't going to work out, they're not going to cost you a bunch of money by mishandling your new patient phone calls or things like that. You want to start them on something innocuous, like reactivation phone calls. I mean, truthfully, if a front desk person can't make reactivation phone calls, regardless of what position they're going into, they're probably not going to work out.
Jeff: That's a good litmus test. Same thing with sterilizing instruments. If they keep screwing up basic things over and over again, or they just called and asked for a 10-year-old for the fourth time because they're not looking at the age of the patient, then you might think, "I might know in a day or two that this person isn't going to work."
Sabri: That's exactly right. And because the hiring process is so traumatic for a lot of dental business owners, they usually hold on to staff way too long. At the end of the day, you look at what their production was, and they made 30 phone calls and scheduled one person, and that was an entire day's worth of production. I might be okay with that on day one. Maybe do some correction. But if by day two or three I don't see that dramatically increase, I already know that this person's concept of what it takes to make it in this office is probably not adequate for their survival in this office.
Jeff: Got it. It's not going to work.
Sabri: It's not going to work.
Jeff: So why burn the time? Because the training, when I actually have to sit with this person and show them the more important details, is going to take time, as the manager or whoever.
Sabri: That's exactly right. So usually I pick reactivation as my litmus test, and in the back I pick sterilization. Even with a hygienist, you can start that hygienist on the first day seeing just regular recall patients. It doesn't have to be anyone with large outstanding treatment plans attached. Let's see how they communicate with patients. I wouldn't put a bunch of new patients on a hygienist's schedule immediately. Let's see if they can do the basics of the job before I start adding to it, and let's make sure they can do it well.
Jeff: So we're assuming that, as we have the hygienist seeing the recall patients, or the new assistant sterilizing, or this person doing reactivation, we're not just tossing them in a room to do this. We're looking at what they're doing. Obviously, with sterilization that's kind of important. So someone's looking at their work.
Sabri: Somebody's looking at their work and making sure they're a good fit and competent enough to do the job, and to warrant further training. Now, once you know they can work, they're competent, they understand, they're trainable, and you can show them how to do something and they execute it and get the result you wanted, you can start adding the other functions, one at a time. You don't add 20, like, "Okay, good, you're going to work. Here's the entire job. Let me show you..." Again, that's just overwhelming. Don't do that. Add one at a time. And this whole process doesn't have to take a long time.
Jeff: Because some people are faster than others, I guess.
Sabri: Correct. Even if it takes a week, or heck, even if it takes two weeks, adding one function at a time until they have a clear command of the job, at least you have somebody who's trained properly and can actually do the job. Versus just throwing somebody on the job, closing your eyes, and praying to whatever deity is listening today that they're not going to screw up your office, which is so expensive. Now, are there better, more efficient ways of training, with manuals and this, that, and the other thing? Absolutely. And is there a very exact way to do that? 100%. But I'm not going to get into that here, because most people don't even have this down.
Jeff: And even properly done manuals, speaking to your point, will be laid out that way, where they start with the easy stuff, with things for them to go do as part of the manual, before you move on to the next part.
Sabri: Correct. You're exactly right. Even if you have a manual that is beautiful, you don't just hand the person the manual and have them study everything until they're completely overwhelmed with words and their head's swimming, and then say, "Okay, let's start." That's not how you train people.
Jeff: Which brings up another interesting point. I just thought of this. Let's say I'm hiring somebody from, I don't know, the customer service space. They have zero dental experience, and they're going to be at the front. So I'm going to do the orientation. Do I go over basic dental terms as well?
Sabri: Yeah, 100%. Otherwise you're speaking a different language. These people don't speak your language yet, and it might take a little bit of time before they do.
Jeff: So you have that baked into the orientation.
Sabri: That's exactly right. When I was in a dental practice, what I used to do with new staff was put them in the back for a day. If they had zero understanding of the back, I wanted them in the back. I didn't care what they did. They could just help clean and turn over rooms. That's easy to teach somebody. So they got a little bit of an idea of what we do and how long things take. They got to see, oh, this is a crown, this is how they do a root canal, this is a filling, this is how long this takes. Because these are the people who are going to be scheduling these things for you. How do you expect them to schedule this if they have no reality on what you're actually doing in the back? You get this massive disconnect. It's almost like you're running two organizations. There's the front and the back.
Jeff: Right.
Sabri: No, it's one organization, and they need to work together as one organization.
Jeff: I think you see that in big companies at times. And this is where I'm thankful that I lecture a lot, so I'm hands-on with clients. We do this with our staff too. We have personnel who aren't interacting with clients day to day, but they do interact with clients at various points.
Sabri: That's exactly right.
Jeff: Because you have to understand, everything here is built around the ability to deliver to clients. Why do I have a personnel department? Why do I have a new sales department? I have them so we can deliver to clients. So if people are completely divorced from the concept of what we do, they're going to lose vision as to why we're here.
Sabri: That's correct. Same thing there. And they're never going to pick up on the culture. They're never going to be excited about what you're doing, because most dentists do incredible work and change people's lives. Well, you need to make sure your staff know that too, because your front desk is selling you, selling spots on your schedule, to your patients.
Jeff: I think that's brilliant. Even if the receptionist did some retraction for a couple of procedures, helped seat a patient, put their bib on, and cleaned a room obviously with oversight, so they don't screw it up.
Sabri: And then walked the patient to the front desk: "How was your appointment?" "It was great. I'm so relieved. The doctor didn't hurt me at all." Let them get some reality on what you do.
Jeff: Okay. All right. Well, I like this. This is basic. This is very simple.
Sabri: Very basic.
Jeff: And it's very doable. Is there anything you would add to it?
Sabri: The only thing I would add is that the biggest mistake I see in hiring, and I know this is a bit of a cliché, is not firing. Even if they're good people, they may not be good for you. And it's interesting. Sometimes I'm with a client, and obviously I know their staff, or at least their names, and I see somebody's gone after having been there for a while. I'm like, "What happened?" "Well, they never really did well. Blah, blah, blah." And I'm like, "When did you think they weren't going to work?" You'd be amazed how many people say, "Listen, I had thoughts when I was interviewing them already." And I'm like, "Oh, my goodness. Why didn't you listen to yourself?"
Jeff: Good point.
Sabri: So I think the biggest thing is, listen to yourself, and talk to your staff. If they need to be corrected, don't gnash your teeth and go home and talk to your spouse about it. There's nothing your spouse is going to do about it. Talk to the staff member.
Jeff: And see if they correct.
Sabri: And see if they correct. Oh, I realized one other download we can give: we have a dental dictionary we can drop onto the episode webpage.
Jeff: Yeah, that'd be great. All right, so we have the dental dictionary, the orientation checklist, and the group interviews. Sabri, thank you so much.
Sabri: You're so welcome.
Jeff: This was awesome. It's basic, it's simple, folks. It's stuff you can start using immediately. Thank you so much for being here this week.
Sabri: You're welcome.
Jeff: Those downloads will be on the episode webpage. There are three. If you have any questions about MGE, you can find us online at mgeonline.com or call us at (800) 640-1140. Folks, have a great week, and we will see you at the next episode.